Research Article
Generic Construction of Forward-Secure Revocable Identity-Based Signature and Lattice-Based Instantiations
Table 1
Security comparison of RIBS schemes.
| Schemes | FS | SKER | SD/RO | SU/EU | RQA | Adaptive | DP |
| SE13 [4] | No | Yes | SD | EU | No | No | CDH | WLH17 [16] | Yes | Yes | SD | EU | No | Yes | q-DHE | HTH17 [34] | No | No | RO | EU | Yes | Yes | SIS/NTRU | XWW20 [13] | No | Yes | RO | EU | Yes | No | SIS | XWW20 [14] | No | No | SD | EU | Yes | No | SIS | XWZ22 [15] | No | Yes | RO | EU | Yes | No | SIS | Con.1+ [28, 29] | Yes | Yes | SD | SU | Yes | No | SIS | Con.1+ [30, 31] | Yes | Yes | RO | SU | Yes | Yes | SIS | Con.2+ [28] | Yes | Yes | SD | SU | Yes | No | SIS | Con.2+ [30] | Yes | Yes | RO | SU | Yes | Yes | SIS | Con.3+ [28, 29] | Yes | Yes | SD | SU | Yes | No | SIS | Con.3+ [30, 31] | Yes | Yes | RO | SU | Yes | Yes | SIS |
|
|