Generic Construction of Forward-Secure Revocable Identity-Based Signature and Lattice-Based Instantiations

Table 1

Security comparison of RIBS schemes.

Schemes	FS	SKER	SD/RO	SU/EU	RQA	Adaptive	DP
SE13 [4]	No	Yes	SD	EU	No	No	CDH
WLH17 [16]	Yes	Yes	SD	EU	No	Yes	q-DHE
HTH17 [34]	No	No	RO	EU	Yes	Yes	SIS/NTRU
XWW20 [13]	No	Yes	RO	EU	Yes	No	SIS
XWW20 [14]	No	No	SD	EU	Yes	No	SIS
XWZ22 [15]	No	Yes	RO	EU	Yes	No	SIS
Con.1+ [28, 29]	Yes	Yes	SD	SU	Yes	No	SIS
Con.1+ [30, 31]	Yes	Yes	RO	SU	Yes	Yes	SIS
Con.2+ [28]	Yes	Yes	SD	SU	Yes	No	SIS
Con.2+ [30]	Yes	Yes	RO	SU	Yes	Yes	SIS
Con.3+ [28, 29]	Yes	Yes	SD	SU	Yes	No	SIS
Con.3+ [30, 31]	Yes	Yes	RO	SU	Yes	Yes	SIS