Review Article

A Comparative Study among Handwritten Signature Verification Methods Using Machine Learning Techniques

Table 5

Comparison between the most used feature extraction techniques.

Feature extraction techniqueAdvantagesLimitations

Contourlet transform (CT)(1) Proper for two-dimensional images processing.Not proper for image coding because of redundant transform
(2) More directions is used in the transformation
(3) Able to remove noises in the smooth areas and along the borders of image in a very good way

Local features(1) The texture in image areas are shown(1) Key-points distinguishing is required
(2) Invariant to scale, rotation, and other transformations(2) Comparing images may be more difficult because of the differing numbers of key-points images.
(3) No spatial information

Global features(1) Charachtarize the whole imageSensitive to clutter and occlusion.
(2) The descriptors of shape and texture are classified into this group of features
(3) Very compact images representations are shown, in which every point in a high-dimensional space of features represent an image.
Structural featuresAble to encode some information about the structure of the objectsSuitable with binary images only

Histogram of oriented gradient (HOG)(1) Both shape and texture are shown(1) Produce a very big feature vectors resulting in large costs of storage
(2) Suatable for objects in detecting when image is processed(2) Cannot deal with scale and rotation
(3) Mainlly used for objects classification(3) Time consuming when it extract features

Statistical features(1) Easily detected as compared with structural features.Suitable only with gray-level and color images
(2) Not influenced very much by noises or distortions as compared to statistical features.

Gray level Co-occurrence matrices (GLCM)(1) It is a measurement of the various combination of brightness value pixels in an image.Feature calculation is a time-wasting process in GLCM
(2) GLCM features is direction independent because it can be gained for a one orientation as well as merging all the orientation together