Research Article

ASTEC–MAAP Comparison of a 2 Inch Cold Leg LOCA until RPV Failure

Table 5

Key results in the SBLOCA predicted by ASTEC and MAAP.

EventASTEC_REFMAAP_REFASTEC_SENMAAP_SEN

Integrated liquid break mass at 200 seconds26600 kg21900 kg26600 kg21900 kg

Integrated liquid break mass at 1e4 seconds143395 kg120830 kg136593 kg120830 kg

Integrated gas break mass at 1e4 seconds68800 kg71924 kg80188 kg66775 kg

Primary pressure at 1500 seconds7.3e6 Pa7.2e6 Pa7.3e6 Pa7.2e6 Pa

Primary pressure at 1e4 seconds1.0e6 Pa2.2e6 Pa1.9e6 Pa1.1e6 Pa

Accumulator discharged mass44.16 tons66.94 tons68.26 tons44.16 tons

In-vessel hydrogen generation528 kg605 kg586 kg502 kg

Total relocated mass167 tons127 tons147 tons127 tons

Highest slumping rate15100 kg/s788 kg/s13100 kg/s607 kg/s

Maximum corium pool temperatures2760 K2850 K2665 K2850 K

Lower head wall location0.4 m below cylinder0.55 m below cylinder0.55 m below cylinder0.55 m below

Type of RPV failureCreep rupture by focusing effectCreep ruptureCreep rupture by focusing effectCreep rupture