Research Article

A Comparative Study on Sensitivity-Based Damage Detection Methods in Bridges

Table 9

Solution time, loops, and RPE of DDM method for model 2.

Damage scenarioSpeed parameter
0.10.30.50.70.9
ST (s)RPE (%)ST (s)RPE (%)ST (s)RPE (%)ST (s)RPE (%)ST (s)RPE (%)

M1-1126.055 2.15E − 03109.767 3.68E − 03111.271 2.64E − 03126.776 3.42E − 03110.576 2.91E − 03
M1-2262.790 4.16E − 03237.909 6.14E − 03230.317 3.34E − 03224.621 5.16E − 03212.940 6.05E − 03
M1-3289.739 5.89E − 03318.109 4.91E − 03292.011 2.87E − 03257.903 4.57E − 03298.917 4.70E − 03
M1-4155.150 5.73E − 03165.956 5.69E − 03165.974 3.22E − 03164.765 2.82E − 03166.811 4.48E − 03
M1-5299.442 3.55E − 03252.091 5.58E − 03329.452 5.02E − 03252.018 6.32E − 03270.098 3.28E − 03
M1-6315.672 4.24E − 03219.352 2.69E − 03263.828 3.36E − 03217.605 3.24E − 03232.333 6.60E − 03