Experimental and Theoretical Study on Influence of Different Charging Structures on Blasting Vibration Energy

Table 1

Peak vibration velocity of different charging structures at measuring points (cm/s).

Charging structure	Proportional distance
Coupling charging	4.281	14.361	11.769	19.666	20.180	6.614~25.986
	8.561	4.136	0.003	7.652	7.936	2.339~10.554
	12.842	3.143	3.244	3.430	4.748	1.273~6.230
Air-decoupling charging	13.922	1.305	2.155	1.814	2.561	0.962~4.888
	14.228	1.753	1.003	1.108	2.481	0.932~4.754
	18.573	0.667	0.003	1.924	1.991	0.625~3.363
	21.341	1.360	0.757	0.888	1.792	0.507~2.806
	23.208	1.210	1.242	0.962	1.671	0.447~2.516
	30.826	1.096	0.677	0.767	1.237	0.292~1.740
Water-decoupling charging	12.747	1.103	1.952	2.483	2.654	1.099~5.484
	16.995	0.574	1.320	0.943	1.618	0.714~3.773
	25.493	0.534	0.003	1.119	1.170	0.388~2.227