Comprehensive Structural Assessment of a Perforated Plate in the Edge and Central Crack

Table 9

Comparing dimensionless values of critical tension load for shell and solid elements.

R (m)	d/b	Nx (n/m)	Kc shell	Kc solid	Kc article
0	0	1985.0	13.79	13.97	13.79
0.0015	0.025	1976.00	13.72	13.93	13.71
0.003	0.05	1950.00	13.54	13.71	13.51
0.006 m	0.1	1859.70	12.90	13.07	12.80
0.012	0.2	1615.00	11.21	11.30	10.82
0.018	0.3	1393	9.67	9.75	8.97
0.024	0.4	1226.4	8.51	8.53	7.51
0.03	0.5	1106	7.67	7.73	6.39
0.036	0.6	1011.7	7.02	7.04	5.63
0.042	0.7	900	6.25	6.31	4.99
0.048	0.8	719	4.99	5.08	4.43