Research Article

Statistical Optimization of Process Parameters for Lipase-Catalyzed Synthesis of Triethanolamine-Based Esterquats Using Response Surface Methodology in 2-Liter Bioreactor

Table 3

The Shapiro-Wilk and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests for five variables.

Conversion (%)LevelKolmogorov-SmirnovShapiro-Wilk
StatisticDfP valueStatisticDfP value

Enzyme amount (% w/w)3.000.120160.2000.962160.694
5.000.161140.2000.926140.271
7.000.188160.1330.967160.784

Reaction time (h)8.000.154160.2000.938160.327
16.000.122140.2000.975140.930
24.000.141160.2000.948160.455

Reaction temperature (°C)55.000.174160.2000.936160.308
60.000.157150.2000.920150.194
65.000.133160.2000.966160.769

Molar ratio (OA : TEA) (mole)1.000.137160.2000.957160.609
2.000.121150.2000.958150.651
3.000.158160.2000.960160.666

Agitation speed (r.p.m.)250.000.155160.2000.946160.431
400.000.146140.2000.932140.330
550.000.104160.2000.971160.856