Review Article

The MicroRNAs as Prognostic Biomarkers for Survival in Esophageal Cancer: A Meta-Analysis

Table 1

Clinicopathological characteristics of eligible studies.

miRNAStudyYearPopulationSampleHistology StagePT (Y/N/U)Sample collectionControl groupGender
(M/F)
AgeMethodKitsECCutoffHRResult

miR-375Komatsu2012JapanPlasmaESCC50I–IV0/50/0Prior to surgerynormal44/6≥65, 25; <65, 25qRT-PCRTaqManU6NormalROS
Kong2012ChinaFrozenESCC60I–IV0/60/0During resectionnormal43/17≤66, 23; >66, 37qRT-PCRSYBRSNORD48NormalSCOS/DFS
Li, J2013ChinaFFPEESCC249I–IVNGArchiveANT136/113≤60, 105; >60, 144qRT-PCRSYBR18sNGSCOS
Mathe2009MarylandFrozenAD730–IV45/27/1During resectionANT63/10<62, 39; ≥62, 34qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
CanadaFrozenAD270–IV0/27/0During resectionANT26/1<62, 12; ≥62, 15 qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
MarylandFrozenESCC240–IV14/9/1During resectionANT12/12<62, 11; ≥62, 13qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
JapanFrozenESCC330–IV15/18/0During resectionANT30/3<62, 14; ≥62, 19 qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
CornellFrozenESCC130–IV4/9/0During resectionANT10/3<62, 3; ≥62, 10qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
Nguyen2010US/CanadaFrozenAD930–IV40/53/0During resectionANT83/1061.7, 93qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
Wu2014ChinaSerumESCC194I–IV0/194/0Prior to surgerynormal115/7961.4, 194qRT-PCRTaqManU6MeanROS
miR-21Hamano2011JapanFFPEESCC98I–IV98/0/0ArchiveANT84/14High: ;
Low:
qRT-PCRTaqManU48MedianSCOS
Hu2011USAFFPEAD1580–IV0/158/0ArchiveANT127/3128–82, median 64ISHNGNGNGROS/DFS
Komatsu2013JapanPlasmaESCC50I–IV0/50/0Prior to surgerynormal44/6≥65, 25; <65, 25qRT-PCRTaqManU6NormalROS
Li, P2013ChinaFrozenESCC76I–IVNGDuring resectionNormal61/15 ≥65, 29; <65, 47qRT-PCRSYBRU65-foldSCDFS
Mathe2009MarylandFrozenAD730–IV45/27/1During resectionANT63/10<62, 39; ≥62, 34qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
CanadaFrozenAD270–IV0/27/0During resectionANT26/1<62, 12; ≥62, 15 qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
MarylandFrozenESCC240–IV14/9/1During resectionANT12/12<62, 11; ≥62, 13qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
JapanFrozenESCC330–IV15/18/0During resectionANT30/3<62, 14; ≥62, 19 qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
CornellFrozenESCC130–IV4/9/0During resectionANT10/3<62, 3; ≥62, 10qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianROS
Tanaka2013JapanSerumESCC64I–IV0/64/0Prior to surgeryNormal49/15≥65, 42; <65, 22qRT-PCRTaqManmiR-39MedianSCPFS
Zhao2013ChinaFrozenESCC178I–III0/178/0During resectionANT108/7034–78, mean 62.2qRT-PCRTaqManU66MedianSCOS
miR-145Feber2011USFrozenAD45I–IV0/45/0During resectionANT38/7NGqRT-PCRNGU6MedianSCOS
Hamano2011JapanFFPEESCC98I–IV98/0/0ArchiveANT84/14High: ;
Low:
qRT-PCRTaqManU48MedianSCOS
Ko2012CanadaFFPEEC25III0/25/0ArchivePSNGNGMicroarrayBeadChipNGMedianSCDFS
Tanaka2013JapanSerumESCC64I–IV0/64/0Prior to surgeryNormal49/15≥65, 42; <65, 22qRT-PCRTaqManmiR-39MedianSCPFS

FFPE, formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded; PT (Y/N/U), preoperative treatment (yes, no, unknown); PS, posttreatment specimens; ISH, in situ hybridization; ANT, adjacent noncancerous tissue; R, reported; SC, survival curve; NG, not given; OS, overall survival; DFS, disease-free survival; PFS, progression-free survival.