Research Article

Screening of Trace Elements in Hair of the Female Population with Different Types of Cancers in Wielkopolska Region of Poland

Table 4

Comparison of available studies in concentrations of trace elements in scalp hair samples of different types of cancer patients and healthy participants.

Reference Concentrations (mean ± SD)Type of cancerMethodAge
(healthy + cancer patients)
SexCountry
Healthy participantsCancer patients

Al (Aluminum)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26] µg/g15.245 ± 15.90921.017 ± 17.556Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16]  µg/kg11.366 ± 12.68516.460 ± 16.313Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

As (Arsenic)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26] µg/g0.239 ± 0.2201.522 ± 1.980Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg0.558 ± 0.7420.458 ± 1.269Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey
Wadhwa et al., 2015 [27]
µg/g
0.58 ± 0.142.94 ± 0.56Breast cancerAASn.i.94 + 47FPakistan
0.58 ± 0.143.05 ± 0.75Cervix cancerAASn.i.94 + 31FPakistan
0.58 ± 0.142.71 ± 0.32Ovarian cancerAASn.i.94 + 19FPakistan
0.58 ± 0.143.55 ± 0.64Mouth cancerAASn.i.94 + 28FPakistan

B (Boron)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26] µg/g0.345 ± 0.3870.704 ± 0.567Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg1.136 ± 1.9151.461 ± 1.972Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Ba (Barium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
1.763 ± 1.8481.488 ± 0.938Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg1.396 ± 1.5131.461 ± 1.972Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Ca (Calcium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
34.372 ± 19.56725.849 ± 7.877Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg30.812 ± 18.80968.250 ± 61.327Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Cd (Cadmium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.175 ± 0.2060.441 ± 0.486Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg0.316 ± 0.4260.209 ± 0.176Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey
Wadhwa et al., 2015 [27]
µg/g
1.4 ± 0.564.27 ± 1.58Breast cancerAASn.i.94 + 47FPakistan
1.4 ± 0.565.75 ± 0.96Cervix cancerAASn.i.94 + 31FPakistan
1.4 ± 0.565.34 ± 1.45Ovarian cancerAASn.i.94 + 19FPakistan
1.4 ± 0.566.73 ± 1.65Mouth cancerAASn.i.94 + 28FPakistan
Pasha et al., 2010 [28]
µg/g
1.675 ± 1.12716.82 ± 13.62Gastrointestinal cancerAAS37–6537 + 36F + MPakistan

Co (Cobalt)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.269 ± 0.3900.664 ± 0.566Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg0.392 ± 0.4673.131 ± 11.057Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Cr (Chromium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.991 ± 0.9501.253 ± 0.891Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg0.934 ± 1.0162.492 ± 4.021Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey
Pasha et al., 2010 [28]
µg/g
2.345 ± 1.0832.509 ± 2.080Gastrointestinal cancerAAS37–6537 + 36F + MPakistan

Cu (Copper)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
11.932 ± 10.43513.546 ± 18.719Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg15.753 ± 16.72724.453 ± 18.465Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
18.00 ± 0.0821.64 ± 1.63Lymphoma AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Khuder et al., 2014 [30]
µg/g
15.512.1Leukaemia XRF16–9339 + 39MSyria
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
18.03 ± 0.5527.30 ± 0.95Esophageal cancer AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Pasha et al., 2010 [28]
µg/g
21.08 ± 5.72630.20 ± 19.03Gastrointestinal cancerAAS37–6537 + 36F + MPakistan

Fe (Iron)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
28.190 ± 23.86532.883 ± 35.260Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg25.052 ± 22.9299.652 ± 6.643Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
22.85 ± 1.30120.34 ± 3.41Lymphoma AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Khuder et al., 2014 [30]
µg/g
35.238.4Leukaemia XRF16–9339 + 39MSyria
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
22.82 ± 1.8122.07 ± 1.70Esophageal cancer AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Pasha et al., 2010 [28]
µg/g
66.35 ± 40.66117.2 ± 77.90Gastrointestinal cancerAAS37–6537 + 36F + MPakistan

Hg (Mercury)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.652 ± 0.5960.473 ± 0.604Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg0.585 ± 0.7131.233 ± 1.367Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

K (Potassium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
11.009 ± 8.22613.231 ± 11.671Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg10.701 ± 9.25215.322 ± 18.655Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Li (Lithium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.503 ± 0.6560.912 ± 0.615Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg0.571 ± 0.5860.595 ± 0.670Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Mg (Magnesium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
41.005 ± 20.74831.276 ± 16.873Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg31.921 ± 21.31528.920 ± 24.203Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
120.34 ± 3.467.46 ± 22.02LymphomaAAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
120.98 ± 10.3274.25 ± 10.01Esophageal cancerAAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan

Mn (Manganese)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.863 ± 0.6750.989 ± 0.924Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg1.144 ± 1.1191.8193 ± 2.160Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Na (Sodium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
28.641 ± 21.89529.666 ± 19.391Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg21.378 ± 15.79823.316 ± 30.458Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Ni (Nickel)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.688 ± 0.7310.571 ± 0.499Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg0.580 ± 0.5471.126 ± 0.800Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
5.37 ± 0.235.92 ± 0.58Lymphoma AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Khuder et al., 2014 [30]
µg/g
1.302.32Leukaemia XRF16–9339 + 39MSyria
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
5.40 ± 0.459.85 ± 0.60Esophageal cancer AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Wadhwa et al. 2015 [27]
µg/g
0.63 ± 0.161.51 ± 0.37Breast cancerAASn.i.94 + 47FPakistan
0.63 ± 0.161.89 ± 0.40Cervix cancerAASn.i.94 + 31FPakistan
0.63 ± 0.161.25 ± 0.51Ovarian cancerAASn.i.94 + 19FPakistan
0.63 ± 0.162.92 ± 0.57Mouth cancerAASn.i.94 + 28FPakistan
Pasha et al., 2010 [28]
µg/g
4.309 ± 2.6315.971 ± 4.622Gastrointestinal cancerAAS37–6537 + 36F + MPakistan

Pb (Lead)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
6.196 ± 7.4913.794 ± 3.292Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg5.090 ± 6.1988.577 ± 19.876Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
15.91 ± 0.7326.31 ± 2.33Lymphoma AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Khuder et al., 2014 [30]
µg/g
10.98.28Leukaemia XRF16–9339 + 39MSyria
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
15.91 ± 0.9926.70 ± 5.97Esophageal cancer AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Pasha et al., 2010 [28]
µg/g
15.50 ± 8.11928.71 ± 16.85Gastrointestinal cancerAAS37–6537 + 36F + MPakistan

Se (Selenium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
5.061 ± 7.5970.649 ± 0.930Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg20.135 ± 21.04213.703 ± 19.784Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Sr (Strontium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.499 ± 0.5020.449 ± 0.419Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg1.455 ± 1.6781.910 ± 1.914Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Ti (Tin)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.708 ± 0.5100.653 ± 0.465Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg2.079 ± 4.46412.638 ± 19.128Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

V (Vanadium)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
0.475 ± 0.4390.640 ± 0.752Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg1.047 ± 1.7421.835 ± 2.290Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey

Zn (Zinc)
Cihan et al., 2011 [26]
µg/g
63.700 ± 62.18329.374 ± 20.367Breast cancer (stage III)ICP/MS25–6552 + 52FTurkey
Benderli Cihan and Öztürk Yildirim, 2011 [16] µg/kg109.763 ± 95.33453.22 ± 60.301Non-small cell lung cancerICP/MS42–7774 + 67MTurkey
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29]
µg/mL
174.99 ± 9.57167.80 ± 13.86Lymphoma AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Khuder et al., 2014 [30]
µg/g
218183Leukaemia XRF16–9339 + 39MSyria
Ahmad et al., 2011 [29] µg/mL175.32 ± 11.48144.85 ± 11.33Esophageal cancer AAS18–80n.i.F + MPakistan
Wadhwa et al., 2015 [27]
µg/g
247 ± 17.4114 ± 14.0Breast cancerAASn.i.94 + 47FPakistan
247 ± 17.4168 ± 31.0Cervix cancerAASn.i.94 + 31FPakistan
247 ± 17.4125 ± 7.63Ovarian cancerAASn.i.94 + 19FPakistan
247 ± 17.4161 ± 24.6Mouth cancerAASn.i.94 + 28FPakistan
Pasha et al., 2010 [28]
µg/g
140.7 ± 79.48370.5 ± 208.1Gastrointestinal cancerAAS37–6537 + 36F + MPakistan
Memon et al., 2007 [21] 
μg/g
245.6 ± 15.6125.5 ± 11.5Ovarian cancerFAAS30–6050 + 35FPakistan
245.6 ± 15.6114.5 ± 12.9Breast cancerFAAS30–6050 + 30FPakistan

Abbreviations: AAS—atomic absorption spectroscopy; FAAS—flame atomic absorption spectrometry; XRF—X-ray fluorescence; n.i.—no information.