Research Article

Environmental Temperature and Thermal Indices: What Is the Most Effective Predictor of Heat-Related Mortality in Different Geographical Contexts?

Table 1

Descriptive statistics for daily all-cause mortality of the very elderly (subjects ≥75 years of age), air pollution, and meteorological parameters measured in urban and suburban areas of Florence and Livorno during the warmest period of the year (May–October) from 2006 to 2008. Mean, standard deviation (SD), and 10th, 75th, and 90th percentiles are shown.

VariablesUnitInland plain city: FlorenceCoastal plain city: Livorno
Mean (±SD)10th 75th90thMean (±SD)10th 75th90th

Mortality age ≥75 years N7.0 (±2.7)49113.5 (±2.0)156
Air pollution
 SO2µg m−31.6 (±0.8)0.81.92.64.3 (±3.9)0.76.09.5
 NO2µg m−338.1 (±11.9)23.545.452.831.5 (±7.2)23.435.240.1
 COµg m−30.6 (±0.2)0.40.70.80.5 (±0.1)0.40.60.7
 O3µg m−370.1 (±20.4)42.983.395.776.0 (±18.0)52.187.999.4
 PM10µg m−330.6 (±11.3)18.635.343.427.7 (±7.9)19.431.237.4
Meteorology
Urban
°C20.6 (±3.8)15.623.925.720.4 (±3.3)16.123.224.7
 RH%40.1 (±13.3)24.648.257.250.0 (±12.6)31.958.464.5
m s−11.7 (±0.7)0.91.92.22.0 (±0.6)1.12.32.9
°C21.1 (±5.9)12.725.728.121.2 (±5.1)13.825.126.9
Suburban
°C21.9 (±4.2)16.425.527.822.6 (±3.6)17.925.427.3
 RH%42.4 (±13.2)25.850.059.661.1 (±16.6)39.472.484.1
m s−13.1 (±0.7)2.23.53.95.5 (±2.5)3.55.88.3
°C22.5 (±6.3)13.627.330.023.2 (±5.2)16.026.929.1

: environmental temperature; RH: relative humidity; : 10 m high horizontal wind speed; : mean radiant temperature.