Quasi-Affine Transformation Evolutionary with Double Excellent Guidance

Table 3

Comparison on 30D optimization under CEC2013 test suite with different algorithms.

Algorithms	QUATRE-DEG	C- QUATRE	QUATRE	MABC	IABC
	Mean/std	Mean/std	Mean/std	Mean/std	Mean/std
	6.17-04/1.1-04	0.00+00/0.0+0(>)	2.23-14/6.8-1(>)	0.00+00/0.0+0(>)	0.00+00/0.0+0(>)
	3.16+05/1.5+05	5.42+05/2.8+0(<)	2.60+05/1.0+0(>)	6.89+07/1.3+0(<)	2.13+07/3.9+0(<)
	1.62+06/4.2+06	4.55+05/1.8+0(>)	2.41+06/4.8+0(<)	3.35+09/8.6+0(<)	4.53+09/1.2+0(<)
	2.39+01/1.6+01	8.33+01/4.9+0(<)	1.59+01/1.0E+0(>)	8.06+04/1.0+0(<)	4.69+04/7.1+0(<)
	3.08-04/5.0-05	9.59-14/4.2-1(>)	1.11-13/1.6-1(>)	0.00+00/0.0+0(>)	0.00+00/0.0+0(>)
	5.01+00/8.0+00	1.05+01/1.3+0(<)	6.51+00/1.1+0(<)	1.76+01/8.9+0(<)	3.59+01/2.4+0(<)
	1.39+01/1.0+01	8.53+00/7.8+0(>)	2.17+01/1.5+0(<)	9.79+01/8.1+0(<)	9.64+01/8.2+0(<)
	2.09+01/5.6-02	2.10+01/5.9-0(<)	2.10+01/5.0-0(<)	2.09+01/5.3-0(=)	2.09+01/6.1-0(=)
	1.65+01/5.3+00	1.51+01/5.6+0(>)	1.69+01/6.3+0(<)	3.43+01/1.2+0(<)	2.92+01/1.9+0(<)
	5.98-02/1.4-02	2.69-02/1.7-0(<)	2.48-02/1.6-0(>)	6.22-01/5.0-0(<)	2.25+00/7.4-0(<)
	2.25+01/5.6+00	1.91+01/5.1+0(>)	2.69+01/7.2+0(<)	9.60+01/8.0+0(<)	0.00+00/0.0+0(>)
	6.19+01/1.9+01	8.75+01/2.4+0(<)	7.87+01/2.5+0(<)	2.28+02/1.2+0(<)	2.84+02/1.2+0(<)
	1.12+02/2.8+01	1.13+02/3.0+0(<)	1.25+02/3.0+0(<)	2.25+02/1.4+0(<)	2.83+02/2.4+0(<)
	6.88+02/2.7+02	6.48+02/2.8+0(>)	8.74+02/3.2+0(<)	4.14+03/2.8+0(<)	9.08+01/3.2+0(>)
	3.77+03/6.1+02	5.59+03/8.8+0(<)	5.23+03/6.2+0(<)	7.37+03/2.9+0(<)	5.00+03/4.2+0(<)
	3.01-01/1.6-01	2.43+00/3.6-0(<)	2.51+00/4.2-0(<)	2.43+00/2.7-0(<)	2.20+00/2.5-0(<)
	4.71+01/4.9+00	4.94+01/5.5+0(<)	5.46+01/6.8+0(<)	1.43+02/8.9+0(<)	3.08+01/1.8-0(>)
	8.61+01/2.5+01	1.74+02/2.3+0(<)	1.69+02/2.4+0(<)	2.52+02/9.2+0(<)	3.30+02/2.8+0(<)
	2.53+00/5.5-01	3.23+00/7.4-0(<)	3.47+00/7.4-0(<)	1.33+01/1.0+0(<)	2.75+00/5.1-0(<)
	1.14+01/6.0-01	1.19+01/5.6-0(<)	1.18+01/5.8-0(<)	1.38+01/2.7-0(<)	1.30+01/3.0-0(<)
	2.93+02/7.5+01	2.93+02/8.8+0(=)	2.84+02/6.5+0(>)	2.61+02/4.9+0(>)	3.28+02/5.8+0(<)
	6.09+02/2.6+02	6.47+02/2.4+0(<)	8.62+02/3.0+0(<)	4.68+03/2.2+0(<)	1.23+02/3.0+0(>)
	3.92+03/7.6+02	5.58+03/6.3+0(<)	5.37+03/8.0+0(<)	7.86+03/3.0+0(<)	5.82+03/5.1+0(<)
	2.31+02/1.1+01	2.32+02/1.4+0(<)	2.37+02/1.2+0(<)	2.87+02/3.4+0(<)	2.53+02/5.9+0(<)
	2.51+02/7.4+00	2.53+02/7.0+0(<)	2.59+02/7.9+0(<)	2.94+02/4.2+0(<)	2.63+02/2.6+0(<)
	2.47+02/6.5+01	2.56+02/6.5+0(<)	2.58+02/6.8+0(<)	2.08+02/1.5+0(>)	2.00+02/5.4-0(>)
	6.43+02/1.1+02	6.34+02/1.0+0(>)	6.51+02/1.0+0(<)	1.12+03/1.5+0(<)	8.71+02/1.0+0(<)
	3.22+02/1.5+02	3.83+02/2.9+0(<)	3.16+02/1.4+0(>)	3.00+02/3.4-1(>)	2.80+02/6.0+0(>)
//		18/1/9	21/0/7	22/1/5	19/1/8