[Retracted] A Comprehensive Review of Lightweight Authenticated Encryption for IoT Devices

Table 6

Authenticated encryption software performance metrics.

Algorithm	Family	Mode	Speed; E/D; (cycles/bytes)	ROM (bytes)	RAM (bytes)	Cycle count; (cycles)	Implementation	Protocol
AES_GCM [167]	BCAE	GCM	E/D: ×	×	367	975184	8 bits AVR	IEEE 802.15.4
AES_GCM [167]	BCAE	GCM	E/D: ×	×	367	2369572	16 bits MSP	IEEE 802.15.4
AES_GCM [167]	BCAE	GCM	E/D: ×	×	367	1197073	32 bits ARM	IEEE 802.15.4
AES-CLOC [112]	BCAE	CLOC	×:750; Per 16 bytes	2980	362	1999	8 bits AVR	×
Scream-10 [149]	BCAE	TAE	×	3221	80	E: 7646	8 bits AVR	×
				Words	Words	D: 7672
AES-SILC [150]	BCAE	SILC	×: 4.9	×	×	×	Intel 64 bits	×
LED-SILC [150]	BCAE	SILC	×: 40	×	×	×	Intel 64 bits	×
ACORN_v2 [168]	SCAE	×	E: 6.38; D: 6.52	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
ACORN_v2 [162]	SCAE	×	E/D: ×	×	184	464381	8 bits AVR	IEEE 802.15.4
ACORN_v2 [162]	SCAE	×	E/D: ×	×	184	626192	16 bits MSP	IEEE 802.15.4
ACORN_v2 [162]	SCAE	×	E/D: ×	×	184	267168	32 bits ARM	IEEE 802.15.4
ACORN_v3 [168]	SCAE	×	E: 6.23	×	×	×	amd64 bits	IEEE 802.15.4
			D: 6.36
ACORN [120]	SCAE	×	E: 54.13	×	×	×	amd64 bits	IEEE 802.15.4
ASCON_v1.2 [162]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E/D: ×	×	183	534908	8 bits AVR	IEEE 802.15.4
ASCON_v1.2 [162]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E/D: ×	×	183	619523	16 bits MSP	IEEE 802.15.4
ASCON_v1.2 [162]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E/D: ×	×	183	83118	32 bits ARM	IEEE 802.15.4
ASCON_v1.2 [120]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E: 16.41	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
ASCON [168]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E: 7.32	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
			D: 7.38
AES-CLOC [120]	BCAE	CLOC	E: 81.76	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
JOLTIK [120]	BCAE	TAE	E: 1590.87	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
PRIMATEs [120]	PBAE	GIBBON	E 6611.66	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
SCREAM [120]	BCAE	TAE	E: 54.58	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
Aegis [120]	BCAE	×	E: 2.15	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
AEZ [120]	BCAE	XEX	E: 4.57	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
Deoxys [120]	BCAE	XEX	E: 16.41	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
AES-OCB [120]	BCAE	XEX	E: 20.35	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
NORX [162]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E/D: ×	×	207	124062	8 bits AVR	IEEE 802.15.4
NORX [162]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E/D: ×	×	207	75727	16 bits MSP	IEEE 802.15.4
NORX [162]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E/D: ×	×	207	16685	32 bits ARM	IEEE 802.15.4
NORX_v3 [168]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E: 6.9	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
			D: 6.92
NORX [120]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	E:11.9	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
LED-SILC [120]	BCAE	SILC	E: 9.9	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
Tiaoxin [120]	SCAE	×	E: 3.53	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
AEZ [120]	BCAE	XEX	E: 4.57	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
Ketje [162]	PBAE	Monkey wrap	E/D: ×	×	158	311949	8 bits AVR	IEEE 802.15.4
Ketje [162]	PBAE	Monkey wrap	E/D: ×	×	158	372720	16 bits MSP	IEEE 802.15.4
Ketje [162]	PBAE	Monkey wrap	E/D: ×	×	158	148381	32bits ARM	IEEE 802.15.4
Ketje [168]	PBAE	Monkey wrap	E: 5.35	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×
			D: 5.34
Ketje [120]	PBAE	Monkey wrap	E: 173.52	×	×	×	amd64 bits	×