Simulations of Heart FunctionView this Special Issue
Research Article | Open Access
Drift of Scroll Wave Filaments in an Anisotropic Model of the Left Ventricle of the Human Heart
Scroll waves are three-dimensional vortices which occur in excitable media. Their formation in the heart results in the onset of cardiac arrhythmias, and the dynamics of their filaments determine the arrhythmia type. Most studies of filament dynamics were performed in domains with simple geometries and generic description of the anisotropy of cardiac tissue. Recently, we developed an analytical model of fibre structure and anatomy of the left ventricle (LV) of the human heart. Here, we perform a systematic study of the dynamics of scroll wave filaments for the cases of positive and negative tension in this anatomical model. We study the various possible shapes of LV and different degree of anisotropy of cardiac tissue. We show that, for positive filament tension, the final position of scroll wave filament is mainly determined by the thickness of the myocardial wall but, however, anisotropy attracts the filament to the LV apex. For negative filament tension, the filament buckles, and for most cases, tends to the apex of the heart with no or slight dependency on the thickness of the LV. We discuss the mechanisms of the observed phenomena and their implications for cardiac arrhythmias.
Spiral and scroll waves are rotating patterns of activity in excitable media . They are found in physical and chemical systems such as oscillating chemical reactions [2, 3] and heterogeneous catalysis . Biological examples of such patterns include populations of Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae , retina , and xenopus oocytes . Some of the most important applications are scroll waves occurring in cardiac tissue , as they underlie the onset of dangerous cardiac arrhythmias [9, 10]. It is extremely important to understand the factors affecting the dynamics of scroll waves in the heart, as they determine the type of cardiac arrhythmia . For example, it has been shown that the drift of scroll waves underlies the onset of polymorphic ventricular tachycardia .
Several factors can induce drift of scroll waves in the heart. Among them are the anisotropy of cardiac tissue and the shape of the cardiac wall. It was shown for two-dimensional spiral waves on curved anisotropic surfaces  that the combination of shape and anisotropy factors results in a drift at a fixed angle with respect to the gradient of the intrinsic curvature of the surface.
For scroll waves, there are additional purely three-dimensional effects which are also likely to contribute to their dynamics in the heart. In particular, it has been shown that the scroll waves drift if their filaments are curved in space and, moreover, the filament length changes monotonically , yielding two distinct regimes . In media with positive filament tension, filament shortens and guarantees the linear stability of the filament shape, whereas in media with negative filament tension, filament length increases . Such dynamics of filaments are very important, as they can potentially lead to the onset of turbulence . Theoretical approaches have also demonstrated that the three-dimensional filament shape is an important determinant of its drift . However, the drift of a scroll wave filament has so far only been studied in simple rectangular geometries. The only studied complex dynamical effect of anisotropy on three-dimensional dynamics is the possible break-up of scroll waves in a discrete  or continuous case .
Recently, we have developed a model of the human heart LV. This model correctly describes the shape and myofibre rotation of the LV . The model is formulated analytically, allowing researchers to modify the LV shape and fibre orientation in a continuous and controlled way. Using it, we can study the effects of shape and anisotropy and the thickness of the cardiac wall on various types of wave dynamics in the heart.
In this paper, we apply our anatomical LV for the study of scroll wave dynamics. We investigate how scroll wave filament dynamics is affected by the anisotropy ratio, thickness of myocardial wall, LV shape, and filament tension. We identify the attractors of filament motion and discuss the possible mechanisms which can account for the observed phenomena.
2.1. Reaction Kinetics
We used the AP model  for cardiac cells and a monodomain description for three-dimensional cardiac tissue:where if and ; otherwise, . To model anisotropic conduction along the cardiac myofibres, a uniaxially anisotropic diffusion tensor is included, with Cartesian components , . Thereby, the diffusion is maximal and equal to along the myofibre direction with unit tangent , and equal to in the transverse direction. At the medium boundaries, no-flux conditions were imposed with the local normal vector .
To investigate the effect of filament tension , the value of the parameter was varied. Note that can be easily measured in silico by adding the small convection term to (1) in two dimensions and measuring the spiral wave drift. For the values of and (see Figure 1 for action potential plots), we, respectively, found and , corresponding to the positive and negative filament tension regimes.
2.2. Geometrical Model
Our anatomical LV model exhibits axisymmetry and uses a variant of spherical coordinates, where indicates longitude and is the downward inclination angle (latitude) with respect to the equatorial plane. The cardiac apex lies at . The transmural position is parameterized by . Explicitly, the curvilinear coordinates relate to the cylindrical coordinates as where is the LV internal (endocardial) radius at the cardiac base, is the basal ring thickness, is the LV cavity depth, and is the wall thickness at the apex (Figure 2). The dimensionless determines the LV sphericity between conical () and ellipsoidal (). Further details of the geometry and the construction of myofibre direction can be found in . The geometrical model includes rotation of the fibre directions from the endocardium to the epicardium with the angle at the base and at the apex.
2.3. Parameter Sets
Every time unit in our model corresponds to 20 ms, and diffusion coefficients are chosen such that one space unit in our model corresponds to 1 mm. Throughout the simulations, the following geometry parameters were kept constant: longitudinal diffusion , full LV height mm, and equatorial wall thickness mm. We used two forms of the LV: sphere-like with , mm, and the normal form with , mm (see Figure 3).
In different simulations, we varied apical thickness between 6 and 18 mm in steps of 2 mm. The transverse diffusion was chosen from , such that the ratio of longitudinal and transverse wave velocities varied between 3 : 1 and 1 : 1.
To initiate a spiral wave, we set the potential equal to 1 in nodes with , , and we set the conductivity equal to in nodes with , . We considered two cases of the initial conditions, namely, when was equal to (the case “4”) and when was equal to (the case “8”).
2.4. Numerical Methods
The mesh used was a rectangular lattice in the coordinates with the size . Time integration was implemented using the Euler method  with time step ms. Since the mesh is highly nonuniform in Cartesian coordinates, we gradually decreased the number of circumferential grid points when approaching the apex as detailed in . Therefore, the mesh we used had nonconstant distances between adjacent nodes. We numerically integrated the system until time s or longer, until we saw the established dynamics of the filament.
The program was written in C language, with OpenMP parallelization, compiled with GCC. Simulations were performed on two supercomputers under Scientific Linux 6.
During the simulations, the position of the scroll wave tip was recorded by finding the intersections of the iso-surfaces , in every layer of constant using the method of . To obtain a 2D representation of a filament for 2D figures and to calculate the drift velocity, we found a mean filament position using averaged value over . To represent average filament position, we calculated a sliding average over two rotations of a scroll wave. Then, we computed the velocity using in finite differences, converted from Cartesian to the special coordinates and assigned phase . Finally, to find position for phase , we averaged positions between phases and .
Visualization of the results was done in Paraview, SharpEye, and Matlab.
We generated heart geometries of two shapes: elliptical (), based on the measurement of the human heart , and spherical (), which mimics the change of heart shape in the case of eccentric and concentric cardiac hypertrophy (see chapter 8 in ). We have also varied the thickness at the apex of the heart and the degree of anisotropy and excitability. We studied how each of these factors affected the dynamics of a scroll wave.
Figure 4 shows typical examples of the dynamics of a scroll wave in our model. The scroll wave was initiated at a central location slightly closer to the apex of the heart (Figure 4(a)). Depending on the geometry of our model and the anisotropy of cardiac tissue, we observed drift of the scroll wave either towards the base of the heart (Figure 4(b), left) or towards the apical region (Figure 4(b), right). In both cases, the vertical motion stabilizes at some distance from the base (apex) and the scroll wave continues a circumferential rotation.
In the next section, we discuss in detail the type of this motion and its dependency on the model geometry and tissue anisotropy.
3.1. Filament Attractors and Their Relation to the Geometry and Anisotropy
We will characterize the position of the filament by a thickness-averaged (i.e., mean) position and represent it as a point in coordinates. Furthermore, since our LV model is axisymmetric, we deal with a systemTherefore, the zeros of determine vertical positions (latitude) where filaments stabilize. In our simulations, we found that filaments after stabilization of their coordinate exhibit residual circumferential drift, since generally .
3.1.1. Drift for Positive Filament Tension
Figure 5 shows the mean filament position after stabilization for the case of positive filament tension (). In all cases, we saw that the filament stabilized at some distance from the apex (or base), after which it continued to drift circumferentially.
The vertical axis of Figure 5 shows the latitude of this attractor, with corresponding to the base of the heart and , to the apex of the heart. We performed simulations for a heart of a spherical shape (panel ) and normal LV form (panel ) for two initial conditions. The apical thickness is shown on the horizontal axis. The basal thickness is always 12 mm; thus, when mm, the base is thicker than the apex, and when mm, the apex is thicker than the base.
General theoretical considerations predict that, in the case of positive filament tension, which we have for , the filament tends to approach the region with the smallest wall thickness .
From Figure 5, we indeed see that, for almost all parameter values, the filaments tend to approach the region of smaller thickness: when mm, it moves towards the apex, and if mm, it drifts towards the base. However, in all cases, the filament does not approach the thinnest region and stops at some distance from it. We also see a large transition zone around mm. Here, the filament stops at a substantial distance from the region with the minimal thickness.
Figure 5 also shows the dependency of the final position of the filament on the initial position of the scroll: the red lines show results for a scroll initially located close to the apex and blue lines for a scroll initially located close to the base. We see that, in most of the cases, the final position of the scroll wave does not depend on the initial conditions; however, for or 18 mm and , we have a substantial change of the position: in those cases, if the scroll is initiated close to the apex, it stays near the apex, independently on its thickness, and this result holds for both a spherical and normal shape of the LV. We performed additional studies for this case and found that scroll waves initially located at latitude were drifting to the base, and for , they stayed near the apex (not shown).
Now, let us try to separate the effects of different components of filament dynamics. First, we characterize the effect of the shape of the ventricle on the final position of the filament. If we compare the final position of the filament for both geometries, we find that, in a spherical shape, the filament is closer to the region of smaller thickness; for example, for mm for all anisotropy ratios, the filament for a spherical LV shape is located closer to the base than for a normal shape ( versus ), and for mm, the filament for the spherical LV shape is located closer to the apex than for a normal shape ( versus ). We also see that the transition from the apical to basal location was more gradual for the normal shape than for the spherical shape.
Secondly, let us consider the effect of anisotropy. We see that, for both shapes and all anisotropy ratios, an increase in the anisotropy ratio results in shifts of the filament towards the apex. Once again, the effect is more substantial for a normal shape, especially for 8 mm mm. For a spherical shape, we also see a shift of the position to the apex, but the effect here is minimal. Thus, anisotropy in our case tends to move the filament towards the apex.
Next, we characterize the trajectory of a scroll wave after approaching the attractor. In all cases, the scroll wave stabilizes at some latitude and then performs a rotational motion around the axisymmetric LV. Figure 6 shows the velocity of this motion for a spherical (Figure 6(a)) and normal shape (Figure 6(b)) with negative velocity accounting for a counterclockwise direction. Note that, in all simulations, the rotation of scroll wave itself was always counterclockwise (as shown in Figure 4), and if the rotation direction of the scroll was changed, all velocities shown in Figure 6 would also change their signs. We see that, for a thick apex mm (i.e., when the scroll approaches the base of the heart) in both cases, the rotation is counterclockwise and its velocity increases with the increase in the anisotropy. For a thin apex mm (i.e., when the scroll approaches the apex of the heart), the velocity is slower and it exhibits a more complex dependency on the anisotropy. For the normal shape, we see that, in the isotropic case, the scroll wave rotates clockwise around the LV. When the anisotropy increases, the velocity of motion decreases and becomes negative for strong anisotropy; that is, the drift motion of a spiral wave around the LV changes to counterclockwise. For the spherical shape in most of the cases, rotation is always clockwise and the dependency on the anisotropy is much smaller.
3.1.2. Drift for Negative Filament Tension
Figure 7 shows the mean filament position after stabilization for the case of negative filament tension (). General theoretical considerations predict that, in the case of negative filament tension, the length of the filament grows and it may lead to the onset of a spatio-temporal chaos .
From Figure 7, we see that we almost never obtain a break-up of the scrolls for these parameter values, and in most cases, the filament stabilizes either at the apex or base. Let us consider first the results for the spherical geometry. We see that the filament drifts to the regions with the thicker wall, and the situation here is somewhat opposite from that for Figure 5. Indeed, for the apical thickness mm, the scroll for most of the cases approaches the apex, and for mm, it most often approaches the base. However, we note a substantial dependency on the initial conditions. If the initial position of the scroll wave is close to the apex (red lines), they are more likely to drift to the apex. If, however, the initial scroll wave is closer to the base (blue lines), the filament may drift to the base even if the base is thinner (see, e.g., the case mm, , blue line).
Secondly, for the normal shape, we see almost no dependency on the LV thickness. For most parameter values, the scroll wave approaches the apex. However, for (blue line), it stays at the base for all values of . It is also difficult to find a clear dependency of the attractor location on the shape of the ventricle. Overall, in most of the cases shown in Figure 7, the scroll wave tends to approach the apex. However, in few cases, as for example, mm, , we observe that, in the spherical geometry, the filaments tend to move towards the apex, while for the normal geometry, it approaches the base (blue line). As we have never seen the opposite situation, we can conclude that, for a spherical shape, there is a slight preference for the scroll wave to move to the apex compared to the normal shape.
We, however, observe a clear effect of anisotropy. In all cases, an increase in the anisotropy ratio resulted in a shift of the attractor to the apex. Thus, as for the positive filament tension, increased anisotropy tends to push the filament towards the apex.
The velocities of a scroll wave after approaching the attractor for negative filament tension shown in Figure 8 substantially differ from the case of the positive tension. We see that velocities here are 50–100 time smaller; that is, the circumferential motion of the filament is almost absent. In most cases, the direction of this motion is counterclockwise.
We have also observed filament break-up for large anisotropy ratio and large apical thickness; that is, and or mm. (For these parameters, data are absent in Figure 7(a).) A typical excitation pattern is shown in Figure 9. We see a break-up pattern, which in this case comprises 4–8 wavelets on the surface of the LV. In some cases, the break-up was transient.
3.2. Mechanisms of Filament Dynamics
To understand the mechanisms of the observed phenomena, we performed a series of two-dimensional simulations in which we studied the drift of a spiral wave on a two-dimensional surface for the following cases: (a) a paraboloidal surface mm close to the endocardial shape of the normal model without anisotropy, (b) a two-dimensional square resembling the anisotropy of the mid-wall endocardium, and (c) the paraboloidal surface of case (a) with the anisotropy of case (b). The initial condition for 2D simulations was a spiral with the same reaction kinetics in an isotropic domain of size 800 mm 800 mm created by evolving a rectangular stimulus in and for 100 time units (2000 ms). The results of these simulations are shown in Figure 10. We see that, for the case of , the spiral is attracted to the apex for all three situations, and its characteristic velocity of motion at a distance mm from the cardiac apex for the isotropic paraboloid is mm/s, mm/s and mm/s, and mm/s for an anisotropic plane with circumferential fibres.
For , both surface shape and anisotropy repel the spiral from the apex, and its characteristic velocity of motion at mm for the isotropic paraboloid is mm/s, and mm/s and mm/s, mm/s for an anisotropic plane with circumferential fibres. Let us consider how these results can be used to explain the observed filament dynamics.
The drift of the filaments studied in the previous section is a combination of three factors which can potentially contribute to the filament dynamics: the thickness of the medium, the anisotropy and the shape of the LV.
First, we consider the effect of wall thickness. From , it is known that filaments with positive tension ( in our case) tend to decrease their length. In such a case, the filaments are expected to stabilize in a region where a local minimum of wall thickness is reached. To compute wall thickness for the given parameters of the shape, we took points on the epicardial and endocardial surfaces. For each value on the endocardium, we found the closest point on the epicardium, occurring at latitude . The Euclidean distance between these two points was then logged as the wall thickness at latitude . Figure 11 shows the resulting wall thickness as a function of latitude , together with the stable loci of filaments for different anisotropy ratios.
For the spherical LV model (, panel a), wall thickness is monotonous and exhibits a minimum at the apex when mm and at the base when mm. In the isotropic case, the final filament state comes close to these expected values. For the normal LV shape (), however, wall thickness exhibits a local minimum in the mid-wall region when mm. Therefore, if the filament moves to the position with minimal length, it is expected to equilibrate at moderate values of latitude . The numerical results in Figures 11(b) and 7(b) confirm this view, since we observe that when is increased, the stable filament position gradually changes from basal to apical.
Next, we turn to the effect of LV shape and anisotropy. It was previously shown  that on two-dimensional surfaces (i.e., thin layers with constant thickness), spiral waves drift according to the gradient of the Ricci curvature, which encompasses both anisotropy and shape. With finite thickness, it can be hypothesized that scroll waves behave like a spiral wave in each layer of constant depth and are therefore sensitive to the anisotropy and curvature in these layers. From our two-dimensional observations in Figure 10, we know that, for , positive curvature attracts spiral waves. Moreover, when circumferential fibres are present in the LV wall, they effectively reduce the circumference of the LV at a fixed latitude if distance is measured according to the arrival time of the excitation waves. Therefore, increasing the anisotropy ratio of circumferential fibres makes a spherical or ellipsoidal shape effectively more elongated. Since such a shape has the increased Ricci curvature close to the apex, it has an attracting effect on spiral waves for , based on our two-dimensional observations in Figure 10. In conclusion, we expect that circumferential fibres around the apex will push the spiral towards the apex. In Figure 11(b), we see that, for an increasing anisotropy ratio, the equilibrium position for filaments indeed shifts closer to the apex.
Now let us consider the case of the negative filament tension. The absence of a break-up for the negative filament tension can be explained by the dependency of this effect on the thickness of the tissue. In , it was shown that if the thickness of cardiac tissue is small, the break-up of a scroll wave due to negative filament tension disappears. This phenomenon was further studied in , where it was shown that filament rigidity increases the effective filament tension in thin media. Although the study  uses a different model for cardiac tissue (i.e., the LuoRudy-1 ionic model), it shows that the critical thickness for the onset of instability there is around 1 cm. In our case, we see a break-up only in the case of a spherical LV shape and when its maximal thickness is above 14 mm. Given the big differences between the models used in our simulations, this value can be considered reasonably close to that obtained in that study .
When the break-up is absent, we observe a drift of transmural filaments. However, in most of the cases, its final position is at the cardiac apex, and for stronger anisotropy, this tendency to go to the apex becomes stronger. Those results are opposite to the results of our two-dimensional simulations, which indicate that, in this case, both geometry and anisotropy repel two-dimensional spiral waves from the apex. This discrepancy can be understood by the observation that, for moderate wall thickness and negative filament tension, filaments will “buckle” and deform into an S-shape, after which they undergo precession . We noted in our simulations that, for , the (Euclidean) length of the filament is always bigger than the wall thickness (see Figure 12), and a visual inspection of the end-state shows that the resulting filament is buckled (see Figure 13). During one rotation period (depicted in Figure 13(b)), the vector connecting the filament endpoints at epicardial and endocardial boundaries also performs a full rotation, albeit in the opposite sense. Therefore, the precession of buckling is phase-locked to scroll wave rotation. This, however, does not explain the tendency of filaments towards the apex. Another factor may be the full three-dimensional anisotropy effects, which deserve further study.
In this chapter, we have presented results on the drift of scroll wave filaments in an anatomical model of human ventricles and have studied the effect of shape, thickness and anisotropy of the ventricle on the drift pattern. We found that the results are substantially affected by the filament tension of the scroll wave.
In the case of the positive filament tension, one of the main determinants of the drift was the thickness of the myocardial wall and the filament tended to drift to the region of minimal thickness. However, in all cases, it never arrived to the point of minimal thickness and rotated at some small distance from it.
Another important determinant of filament drift was the anisotropy of the tissue. Its main effect in our simulations was the attraction of the scroll wave to the apex. The LV shape had a small effect on the results in terms of the direction of the drift. However, it affected the location of the attractor, especially when the gradient in the thickness was not large.
As cardiac tissue has a high excitability in normal conditions, one would expect that in normal conditions, the filament would be located close to the region of minimal thickness with a slight preference towards the apex, due to anisotropy effects. This information might be important for identifying sources of arrhythmias in the heart, with applications in the planning of successive clinical intervention.
We have also studied the case of negative filament tension. In that case, filaments generally behave chaotically, and this normally results in the break-up of scroll waves . In our case, we find that such a break-up can only occur in a small parameter range. In most other cases, the filament was drifting to a stable attractor, and its location was close to the region of maximal thickness in a few cases. However, we observed that scroll waves were much more likely to approach the apex of the ventricle than its base. We again found that the anisotropy of the heart substantially affects the motion by attracting the scroll to the apex; this effect cannot be explained by simple two-dimensional simulations and theory. The LV shape also had a small affect on the scroll wave motion, but for the normal shape, we saw more motion to the apex than for a spherical shape. Thus, in this case, we can say that the elliptic shape induced some attraction force towards the apex of the heart.
The mechanisms underlying the observed phenomena in the regime of positive filament tension can be partially explained by the existing theories of filament dynamics. As such filaments strive to minimize their length, they move to regions of minimal wall thickness. However, we found in our simulations that even in the isotropic case, the filaments did not exactly reach that minimum. Possible disturbing factors are filament twist , curvature of the endocardial and epicardial boundaries, and discretization effects. In two-dimensional simulations, it was seen that spiral waves in the high excitability regime are attracted to regions of positive curvature, such as the cardiac apex, in contrast to a previous study in Barkley’s model . Since positive curvature is amplified by the anisotropy of circumferential myofibres, we understand that an increased anisotropy ratio pushes the filaments closer to the cardiac apex.
In the regime of negative tension, the wall thickness proved in most cases to be insufficient for the development of a full three-dimensional break-up. Instead, we identified buckled filaments which also equilibrate at a given latitude, due to the axial symmetry of our LV model. A further theoretical consideration of the effects of shape and anisotropy on scroll wave dynamics would be nontrivial. Possible ways to approach this problem are to consider shapes with a small thickness and to use averaging methods as in . For thick shapes, one can use the equations of filament dynamics in a general anisotropic medium derived in . However, incorporating the effect of curved domain boundaries on the filament and reconciling those with bulk motion remains a difficult task.
We performed our simulations using the AP model, which provides a simplified description of cardiac tissue. Two-variable models allow researchers to easily obtain various regimes of filament tension, and they are much more efficient for large-scale numerical simulations. Therefore, two-variable models of cardiac tissue are widely used in studies of two-dimensional and three-dimensional dynamics of spiral waves in the heart (see, e.g., ). The next logical step would be to extend these simulations to an ionic model for human cardiac tissue and to find out how the present results are affected.
We have studied only filaments extending from the epicardial to the endocardial surface. It would also be interesting to study the dynamics of the intramural filaments. Such filaments can occur during the normal excitation of cardiac tissue and may have a complex shape and therefore complex dynamics .
In this chapter, we have studied the motion of scroll waves in a homogeneous model of cardiac tissue. It was shown that the heterogeneity of cardiac tissue substantially affects the motion of vortices and their dynamics . The presence of heterogeneity can shift the locations of found attractors and can also result in the onset of new vortices . It would be interesting to study the effect of the transmural heterogeneity and apex base heterogeneity [33, 34] on the results obtained in this chapter. In addition, the presence of the Purkinje network and pectinate muscles may also affect filament dynamics and should be studied in the future.
The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the paper.
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.
Hans Dierckx was funded by the F.W.O.-Flanders; his project includes the theoretical research of scroll waves. Sergei Pravdin, Vladimir S. Markhasin, and Alexander V. Panfilov were supported by The Russian Science Foundation (Project 14-35-00005 for Ural Federal University includes the numerical research of scroll waves). Sergei Pravdin was also supported by Ghent University (Grant 01SF1511 includes the development of algorithms and software for modelling electrophysiological activity of the heart using the analytical LV model). Simulations were performed at the HPC infrastructure of Ghent University (Belgium) and at the supercomputer Uran of Institute of Mathematics and Mechanics (Ekaterinburg, Russia).
- A. T. Winfree and S. H. Strogatz, “Organizing centers for three-dimensional chemical waves,” Nature, vol. 311, no. 5987, pp. 611–615, 1984.
- A. N. Zaikin and A. M. Zhabotinsky, “Concentration wave propagation in two-dimensional liquid-phase self-oscillating system,” Nature, vol. 225, no. 5232, pp. 535–537, 1970.
- A. T. Winfree, “Spiral waves of chemical activity,” Science, vol. 175, no. 4022, pp. 634–636, 1972.
- R. Imbihl and G. Ertl, “Oscillatory kinetics in heterogeneous catalysis,” Chemical Reviews, vol. 95, no. 3, pp. 697–733, 1995.
- F. Siegert and C. J. Weijer, “Three dimensional scroll waves organize dictyostelium slugs,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 89, no. 14, pp. 6433–6437, 1992.
- N. A. Gorelova and J. J. Bures, “Spiral waves of spreading depression in the isolated chicken retina,” Journal of Neurobiology, vol. 14, no. 5, pp. 353–363, 1983.
- J. Lechleiter, S. Girard, E. Peralta, and D. Clapham, “Spiral calcium wave propagation and annihilation in Xenapus laevis oocytes,” Science, vol. 252, no. 5002, pp. 123–126, 1991.
- I. R. Efimov, V. Sidorov, Y. Cheng, and B. Wollenzier, “Evidence of three-dimensional scroll waves with ribbon-shaped filament as a mechanism of ventricular tachycardia in the isolated rabbit heart,” Journal of Cardiovascular Electrophysiology, vol. 10, no. 11, pp. 1452–1462, 1999.
- M. A. Allessie, F. I. M. Bonke, and F. J. G. Schopman, “Circus movement in rabbit atrial muscle as a mechanism of tachycardia. III. The ‘leading circle’ concept: a new model of circus movement in cardiac tissue without the involvement of an anatomical obstacle,” Circulation Research, vol. 41, no. 1, pp. 9–18, 1977.
- J. M. Davidenko, A. V. Pertsov, R. Salomonsz, W. Baxter, and J. Jalife, “Stationary and drifting spiral waves of excitation in isolated cardiac muscle,” Nature, vol. 355, no. 6358, pp. 349–351, 1992.
- A. Garfinkel, P.-S. Chen, D. O. Walter et al., “Quasiperiodicity and chaos in cardiac fibrillation,” Journal of Clinical Investigation, vol. 99, no. 2, pp. 305–314, 1997.
- A. Garfinkel and Z. Qu, “Nonlinear dynamics of excitation and propagation in cardiac tissue,” in Cardiac Electrophysiology: From Cell to Bedside, D. P. Zipes and J. Jalife, Eds., pp. 315–320, Saunders, Philadelphia, Pa, USA, 3rd edition, 2000.
- H. Dierckx, E. Brisard, H. Verschelde, and A. V. Panfilov, “Drift laws for spiral waves on curved anisotropic surfaces,” Physical Review E: Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics, vol. 88, no. 1, Article ID 012908, 2013.
- V. N. Biktashev, A. V. Holden, and H. Zhang, “Tension of organizing filaments of scroll waves,” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series A: Mathematical, Physical Sciences and Engineering, vol. 347, no. 1685, pp. 611–630, 1994.
- A. V. Panfilov and A. N. Rudenko, “Two regimes of the scroll ring drift in the three-dimensional active media,” Physica D. Nonlinear Phenomena, vol. 28, no. 1-2, pp. 215–218, 1987.
- S. Alonso, F. Sagués, and A. S. Mikhailov, “Taming winfree turbulence of scroll waves in excitable media,” Science, vol. 299, no. 5613, pp. 1722–1725, 2003.
- J. P. Keener, “The dynamics of three-dimensional scroll waves in excitable media,” Physica D Nonlinear Phenomena, vol. 31, no. 2, pp. 269–276, 1988.
- A. V. Panfilov and J. P. Keener, “Re-entry in three-dimensional Fitzhugh-Nagumo medium with rotational anisotropy,” Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, vol. 84, no. 3-4, pp. 545–552, 1995.
- F. H. Fenton and A. Karma, “Vortex dynamics in three-dimensional continuous myocardium with fiber rotation: filament instability and fibrillation,” Chaos, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 20–47, 1998.
- S. F. Pravdin, V. I. Berdyshev, A. V. Panfilov, L. B. Katsnelson, O. Solovyova, and V. S. Markhasin, “Mathematical model of the anatomy and fibre orientation field of the left ventricle of the heart,” BioMedical Engineering Online, vol. 12, no. 1, article 54, 2013.
- R. R. Aliev and A. V. Panfilov, “A simple two-variable model of cardiac excitation,” Chaos, Solitons and Fractals, vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 293–301, 1996.
- S. F. Pravdin, H. Dierckx, L. B. Katsnelson, O. Solovyova, V. S. Markhasin, and A. V. Panfilov, “Electrical wave propagation in an anisotropic model of the left ventricle based on analytical description of cardiac architecture,” PLoS ONE, vol. 9, no. 5, Article ID e93617, 2014.
- D. D. J. R. Streeter, “Gross morphology and fiber geometry of the heart,” in Handbook of Physiology, Volume I. The Heart, section 2, pp. 61–112, American Physiological Society, Bethesda, Md, USA, 1979.
- P. Ramrakha and J. Hill, Eds., Oxford Handbook of Cardiology, Oxford University Press, 2nd edition, 2012.
- S. Alonso and A. V. Panfilov, “Negative filament tension in the Luo-Rudy model of cardiac tissue,” Chaos, vol. 17, no. 1, Article ID 015102, 2007.
- H. Dierckx, H. Verschelde, O. Selsil, and V. N. Biktashev, “Buckling of scroll waves,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 109, no. 17, Article ID 174102, 2012.
- I. V. Biktasheva, H. Dierckx, and V. N. Biktashev, “Drift of scroll waves in thin layers caused by thickness features: asymptotic theory and numerical simulations,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 114, no. 6, Article ID 068302, 5 pages, 2015.
- H. Verschelde, H. Dierckx, and O. Bernus, “Covariant stringlike dynamics of scroll wave filaments in anisotropic cardiac tissue,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 99, no. 16, Article ID 168104, 2007.
- A. V. Panfilov and A. V. Holden, “Computer simulation of re-entry sources in myocardium in two and three dimensions,” Journal of Theoretical Biology, vol. 161, no. 3, pp. 271–285, 1993.
- K. I. Agladze, V. I. Krinsky, A. V. Panfilov, H. Linde, and L. Kuhnert, “Three-dimensional vortex with a spiral filament in a chemically active medium,” Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 38–42, 1989.
- A. N. Rudenko and A. V. Panfilov, “Drift and interaction of vortices in two-dimensional heterogeneous active medium,” Studia Biophysica, vol. 98, pp. 183–188, 1983.
- A. V. Panfilov and B. N. Vasiev, “Vortex initiation in a heterogeneous excitable medium,” Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena, vol. 49, no. 1-2, pp. 107–113, 1991.
- C. Antzelevitch and J. Fish, “Electrical heterogeneity within the ventricular wall,” Basic Research in Cardiology, vol. 96, no. 6, pp. 517–527, 2001.
- F. L. Burton and S. M. Cobbe, “Dispersion of ventricular repolarization and refractory period,” Cardiovascular Research, vol. 50, no. 1, pp. 10–23, 2001.
Copyright © 2015 Sergei Pravdin et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.