Application of Systems Biology and Bioinformatics Methods in Biochemistry and Biomedicine 2014View this Special Issue
Research Article | Open Access
An Integrated Modeling and Experimental Approach to Study the Influence of Environmental Nutrients on Biofilm Formation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa
The availability of nutrient components in the environment was identified as a critical regulator of virulence and biofilm formation in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. This work proposes the first systems-biology approach to quantify microbial biofilm formation upon the change of nutrient availability in the environment. Specifically, the change of fluxes of metabolic reactions that were positively associated with P. aeruginosa biofilm formation was used to monitor the trend for P. aeruginosa to form a biofilm. The uptake rates of nutrient components were changed according to the change of the nutrient availability. We found that adding each of the eleven amino acids (Arg, Tyr, Phe, His, Iso, Orn, Pro, Glu, Leu, Val, and Asp) to minimal medium promoted P. aeruginosa biofilm formation. Both modeling and experimental approaches were further developed to quantify P. aeruginosa biofilm formation for four different availability levels for each of the three ions that include ferrous ions, sulfate, and phosphate. The developed modeling approach correctly predicted the amount of biofilm formation. By comparing reaction flux change upon the change of nutrient concentrations, metabolic reactions used by P. aeruginosa to regulate its biofilm formation are mainly involved in arginine metabolism, glutamate production, magnesium transport, acetate metabolism, and the TCA cycle.
Forming biofilms is one of the major strategies implemented by pathogens to survive antibiotic treatment, and biofilms cause chronic human infections . It is reported that 10 to 1000 times higher doses of antibiotics are required to treat pathogens in a biofilm [2, 3]. Investigation of the factors that influence microbial biofilm formation is thus important for combating biofilms associated with pathogens. This research topic has attracted extensive experimentation. For example, the genes that are upregulated during P. aeruginosa biofilm formation have been identified experimentally . Since microbial metabolism depends on the interaction of hundreds to thousands of metabolic reactions, systems-level modeling approaches that can incorporate existing experimental data are essential to pinpoint the factors that play a crucial role in microbial biofilm formation.
Extensive research on modeling microbial biofilms has been conducted in the last 30 years (see Wang and Zhang, 2010 , for a detailed review). However, all these models use the Monod kinetics to quantify the microbial growth rate, that is, the growth rate in which is the substrate concentration and and are the maximum growth rate and half-velocity constant, respectively. No information is thus obtained from these models to quantify the influence from the environmental nutrients on the intracellular microbial metabolism and thus the biofilm formation. Moreover, none of these methods has systematically studied biofilm formation based on the availability of environmental nutrients. On the other hand, genome-scale models have been shown to integrate the extracellular environmental conditions with the intracellular metabolic reactions . On the basis of the genome-scale model developed by Oberhardt et al., 2008 , the Ines Thiele group from University of Iceland  proposed the first systems-biology approach to identify gene targets to terminate the growth of P. aeruginosa in the biofilm. This approach mainly constrained the nutrient uptake rates to mimic the mature biofilm environment and performed single/double in silico gene knockouts to determine the gene targets essential for microbial growth in the biofilm. However, biofilm formation ability of the mutants, which may not be reflected by the microbial growth, has not been studied in this approach. In particular, a slowly growing mutant may form more biofilm than a fast-growing mutant. To address this problem, we developed a systems-level approach to identify gene targets to prevent the biofilm formation of P. aeruginosa, and we found that genes essential to microbial growth are not necessarily good targets to treat P. aeruginosa biofilm, as most of the essential gene mutants form more biofilms before they are completely eliminated by antibiotics . While these existing metabolic modeling approaches mainly focus on the influence of metabolic genes on biofilm formation, no modeling approach has been published to quantify the microbial biofilm formation upon the change in the environmental nutrient conditions; however, the availability of environmental nutrients has been shown to influence microbial biofilm formation. For example, some strains of Escherichia coli K-12 and Vibrio cholerae were reported not to form biofilms in minimal medium unless the medium is supplemented with amino acids . In addition to amino acids, ions such as ferrous ions, phosphate, and sulfate also play an important role in regulating biofilm formation [11, 12]. For example, phosphate influences the biofilm formation of Pseudomonas fluorescens by controlling secretion of adhesion LapA to the surface , and ferrous ions are important for the maturation of P. aeruginosa biofilms .
In this work, we developed the first systems-biology approach to quantify P. aeruginosa biofilm formation based upon the availability of environmental nutrients that include 20 amino acids and three ions (i.e., sulfate, phosphate, and ferrous ions). Specifically, we further extended our previous modeling approach that was developed to determine gene targets to eliminate P. aeruginosa before it forms a biofilm . The idea behind that approach was using the change of fluxes of reactions positively associated with P. aeruginosa biofilm formation (henceforth biofilm-associated reactions) to classify single mutants into different categories. Based upon these categories, targets to prevent P. aeruginosa biofilm formation were identified. Unlike our previous modeling approach, the availability of a specific nutrient component, instead of the expression of a specific metabolic gene, was manipulated here. In addition, a new formula was defined to quantify the microbial biofilm formation from the flux change through the biofilm-associated reactions. The modeling work was based upon the metabolic model of P. aeruginosa originally developed and updated by the Papin group at the University of Virginia (Oberhardt et al., 2008 and 2010 [7, 15]). In particular, the reaction “Rha-(a1,3)-GlcNac-pyrophosphorylundecaprenol synthesis” (RHA1GLCNACPPUNDs) was altered in the updated model to produce guanosine monophosphate (GMP) instead of uridine monophosphate (UMP). The updated model (i.e., Oberhardt et al., 2010 ) was obtained from Papin group by personal communication. This model was used because its previous version has been recently used to successfully predict the phenotype of P. aeruginosa in biofilms (refer to Sigurdsson et al., 2012 , and Xu et al., 2013 , for two examples). Based on the selected metabolic model, flux changes through reactions that were identified to be positively associated with P. aeruginosa biofilm formation (i.e., biofilm-associated reactions) were used to quantify the biofilm formation of P. aeruginosa upon the change in the availability of nutrient components including 20 amino acids and three ions (i.e., ferrous ions, phosphate, and sulfate). These nutrient components were selected in this work due to their importance for the regulation of P. aeruginosa biofilm formation. Data from the literature were used to validate our results for the 20 amino acids. In addition, we conducted the first complete experimental evaluation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm formation for a large change in the concentrations of sulfate, phosphate, and ferrous ions to verify the results for these three ions. Both starved and rich nutrient conditions for each nutrient component were studied in this work.
An illustrative example is shown in Figure 1 to outline our approach to quantify the formation of P. aeruginosa biofilm for different availabilities of nutrient components in the environment. This is followed by a detailed description of the results for P. aeruginosa biofilm formation upon the change in the availability of each of 20 amino acids, ferrous ions, phosphate, and sulfate.
2.1. An Illustration Example of the Proposed Approach
Figure 1 shows an illustrative example to outline our approach for quantifying biofilm formation ability of P. aeruginosa for a specific nutrient condition. First, the change of the nutrient availability can be mimicked by changing the maximum uptake rate of the nutrient component in the flux balance analysis  (refer to Section 4 for more details of flux balance analysis). For example, a zero maximum uptake rate is assigned to arginine for the minimal medium without arginine (referred to as reference nutrient condition), and a maximum 10 mmol gDW−1 h−1 uptake rate, suggested by Oberhardt et al., 2008 , is used to mimic the adding of arginine into minimal medium (referred to as the changed nutrient condition). The flux balance analysis is then performed based on the metabolic model and the uptake constraints for both reference and changed nutrient conditions (Figure 1(a)), and the fluxes through the biofilm-associated reactions are sampled and represented as flux distributions for both conditions (Figure 1(b)). Biofilm-associated reactions are 39 reactions that were identified to be positively associated with P. aeruginosa biofilm formation from the genetic determinant data published in Müsken et al., 2010 . They are mainly related to nitrite consumption, acetate production, the TCA cycle, carbon dioxide production, pyrimidine metabolism, and oxidative phosphorylation. Interested readers can refer to our previous work  for the details of these 39 biofilm-associated reactions. On the basis of the flux distributions shown in Figure 1(b), we further quantified the flux change through each biofilm-associated reaction and obtain a flux-change curve across all biofilm-associated reactions (Figure 1(c)). A criterion named biofilm formation capability is determined from this flux-change curve to quantify the trend for P. aeruginosa to form biofilms upon the change of the availability of a specific nutrient component (e.g., adding arginine into minimal medium) (Figure 1(d)). Biofilm formation capability is actually defined as the ratio of the fluxes through biofilm-associated reactions for the changed nutrient condition (e.g., minimal medium with the addition of arginine) over the ones for the reference nutrient condition (e.g., minimal medium without arginine). In particular, enhanced fluxes through most biofilm-associated reactions result in a large value of biofilm formation capability, which indicates that the changed nutrient availability induces P. aeruginosa to form more biofilm. Only the availability of a nutrient component is changed in Figure 1, although the developed framework can be applied to study the influence of multiple nutrient components on P. aeruginosa biofilm formation. Finally, the biofilm-associated reactions with large flux changes are identified from the flux-change curve (Figure 1(e)). These reactions may reveal the mechanisms used by the pathogen to adjust its biofilm formation under different nutrient conditions.
2.2. Influence of the Availability of Amino Acids in the Medium on P. aeruginosa Biofilm Formation
In this section, the trend for planktonic P. aeruginosa to form a biofilm upon adding an amino acid to the minimal medium was quantified. The minimal medium was thus used as the reference nutrient condition in which P. aeruginosa stayed in the planktonic growth mode. Only one amino acid was added into the minimal medium at a time, which represented a changed nutrient condition. The capability of planktonic P. aeruginosa to form a biofilm for each changed nutrient condition was determined and compared with the experimental data presented by Bernier et al., 2011  (Figure 2). A zerofold increase of biofilm formation shown in Figure 2 means the biofilm formation for the changed condition is the same as that for the reference condition. The experiment data show that (1) adding any of the 20 amino acids into the minimum medium results in the biofilm formation; (2) the supplementation of any of the following 11 amino acids, that is, Arg, Tyr, Phe, His, IlE, Orn, Pro, Asp, Glu, Leu, and Val, can significantly enhance biofilm formation; (3) adding any other amino acid only induces minor biofilm formation. As shown in Figure 2, the model predicted biofilm formation matches these observations very well. In particular, the addition of any of the aforementioned 11 amino acids was predicted to enhance at least onefold biofilm formation, while the supplementation of any other amino acids (especially Cyst, Trp, Thm, and Met) only leads to limited biofilm formation.
In order to further study the biofilm formation mechanism stimulated by the addition of amino acids, we calculated the flux change through each biofilm-associated reaction upon the addition of each of the aforementioned 11 amino acids that significantly enhance biofilm formation. Based upon this, the average flux change through each biofilm-associated reaction over the addition of the 11 amino acids was calculated. The top 10 biofilm-associated reactions with large average flux change were listed in Table 1, and the average flux change of these reactions was shown in Figure 3. The average flux change through Rxn 1 to Rxn 3 is increased more than 3-fold upon the addition of each of the 11 amino acids into the medium. These three reactions are mainly related to the ammonia production, arginine metabolism, and pyruvate metabolism. On the other hand, Rxn 4 to Rxn 10 have two to threefold increase in their average flux change. These reactions are involved in the arginine metabolism (Rxn 4 and Rxn 7), pyridoxine metabolism (Rxn 5), glutamate production (Rxn 6), pyruvate metabolism (Rxn 8), quorum sensing (Rxn 9), and CO2 production (Rxn 10). Therefore, upon the additional availability of amino acids, P. aeruginosa form more biofilm mainly through the regulation of arginine metabolism, pyruvate metabolism, and pyridoxine metabolism and the production of ammonia, quorum sensing component, and CO2. These observations were implied by some existing literature data. For example, it was reported that the availability of arginine  and production of ammonia  and CO2  are positively correlated with P. aeruginosa biofilm formation.
2.3. Influence of the Availability of Ferrous Ions, Sulfate, and Phosphate in the Medium on P. aeruginosa Biofilm Formation
In the following text, the proposed approach was further applied to quantify P. aeruginosa biofilm formation upon different availability levels of inorganic ions that include ferrous ions, sulfate, and phosphate. Experiment for four different concentrations of each ion was performed to quantify the biofilm formation and biomass growth of P. aeruginosa. In order to compare the biomass growth rate and biofilm formation across different concentrations of each ion, the biomass growth rate and biofilm formation for one concentration were used as the reference values to normalize the biomass growth rate and biofilm formation for the other three concentrations. The reference concentration for each of the three ions is shown in Table 2. Four concentrations, that is, 0.05-, 0.5-, 1-, and 5-fold, of the reference concentration were investigated experimentally for each ion so that both the starved and rich ion conditions were covered. The details of the experimental design are given in Section 4.
The calculated biomass growth rate and biofilm formation for nonreference concentrations were normalized by the values for the reference concentration. Selecting concentrations other than those shown in Table 2 as the reference concentration will only change the format to present the results but will not change the results. In the calculation, the uptake rate of each target ion was regulated so that the model-predicted biomass growth rate matched the corresponding experimental data. The fluxes through the 39 biofilm-associated reactions were quantified for each ion concentration to quantify the biofilm formation (see Section 4 for the detailed formula). The model predicted biofilm formation capability was then compared to the experimentally measured biofilm formation data.
The biomass growth rate and biofilm formation of P. aeruginosa upon the change in the availability of ferrous ions were quantified and compared with our own experimental data (Figure 4). It can be seen from Figure 4(a) that the biomass growth rate increases to its maximum value and then deceases upon the increase of ferrous ions from the starved concentration. On the other hand, the biofilm formation is promoted for a low iron concentration and then repressed for increasing iron concentrations until the iron concentration is high enough. The experimental results shown in Figure 4 are implied by some existing studies that have been undertaken to determine how iron affects biofilm formation by P. aeruginosa. For example, researchers found that a minimum amount of free iron was necessary in order for P. aeruginosa to form structured biofilm in flow chambers [19, 20] and low iron concentration promoted P. aeruginosa biofilm formation in artificial cystic fibrosis sputum medium . In addition, increasing iron concentrations to a certain high value suppressed P. aeruginosa biofilm in both microtiter plates and flow chambers [22, 23]. Furthermore, Yang et al. (2007) found that pqs quorum-sensing related genes and the level of extracellular DNA (eDNA) were upregulated in low iron conditions promoting P. aeruginosa biofilm formation and that increasing iron to high concentrations downregulates pqs genes and eDNA formation, thereby decreasing biofilm formation . The experimental result is in agreement with the part that biofilm level is elevated with low iron condition and inhibited with increasing iron to certain concentrations. Figure 4(b) shows that our modeling approach correctly predicts the trend of the biofilm formation for a variety of iron concentrations. In particular, the predicted biofilm formation for medium and high iron concentration matches experimental data well, especially for the iron concentration equal to 5-fold of the reference concentration. The model prediction also underestimated the biofilm formation for the low iron concentration (i.e., 0.05-fold of the reference iron concentration), which may be due to the lack of the regulation in the model for microbial metabolism which is controlled by quorum sensing signaling (e.g., the pqs quorum-sensing mentioned above). Specifically, not all signaling proteins that are regulated by quorum sensing are incorporated in the metabolic network, as they are not the metabolic enzymes that directly regulate bacterial growth.
The experimental and model-predicted results for the biomass growth rate and biofilm formation upon the change in the availability of sulfate concentrations in the medium are given in Figure 5. In particular, Figure 5(a) shows that the biomass growth rate decreases while the biofilm formation increases upon the increase of the sulfate concentration in the medium. While few existing experimental data were found in the literature on the relationship between sulfate and biofilm formation by P. aeruginosa, we here provided new experimental data in this field. Our modeling approach indicates the same trend in P. aeruginosa biofilm formation as the one shown in the experimental data. The model-predicted biofilm formation for the medium and high sulfate concentrations matched the measured value very well, while the model overestimated the biofilm formation for the low sulfate concentration.
The biomass growth rate and the biofilm formation predicted by our modeling approach for these four phosphate concentrations were plotted with the corresponding experimental data in Figure 6. It can be seen that the biomass growth rate increases to its peak value and then decreases upon the increase in the availability of phosphate (Figure 6(a)). On the other hand, the biofilm formation displays the same trend as the biomass growth in the experimental data, as little biofilm is formed for very low or high phosphate concentrations (Figure 6(b)). Low phosphate conditions were shown to trigger virulence in P. aeruginosa . A study was conducted where Caenorhabditis elegans worms were allowed to feed on nonvirulent P. aeruginosa grown in either high or low phosphate medium. Worms that fed on P. aeruginosa grown in low phosphate medium developed large red spots on their intestine and 60% of them eventually died (red death syndrome) whereas no nematodes that fed on high phosphate grown P. aeruginosa died . This result suggests that there is more biofilm with low phosphate. Further study has elucidated that phosphate depletion leads to increase in biofilm formation as well as expression of PA-I lectin (causes sepsis by disrupting the intestinal epithelial barrier) and pyocyanin (responsible for neutrophil apoptosis) in P. aeruginosa . These findings, which were not designed for the starved phosphate conditions, corroborate our experimental result where biofilm formation decreases with increasing phosphate concentration (from 0.5 to 5). Our data provided additional information for the biofilm formation for phosphate starvation condition (0.05-fold of the reference concentration). The model-based predicted biofilm formation by P. aeruginosa presents a similar trend to the one shown in the experimental data for low and medium phosphate concentrations. In particular, our modeling approach predicts the biofilm formation for the concentration of 0.5-fold quite well, although it overestimates the biofilm formation for both the low and high phosphate concentrations (i.e., 0.05- and 5-fold, resp.).
In order to further investigate the mechanisms used by P. aeruginosa to facilitate its biofilm formation under different availability of phosphate, sulfate, and ferrous ions, the change in the fluxes of the 39 biofilm-associated reactions was evaluated for each of the three ions. Compared to amino acids, the change in the availability of ions does not lead to much change in biofilm formation. This can be reflected in relatively small change in the fluxes through those biofilm-associated reactions. For each of the three ions, the metabolic reactions whose fluxes are of more than 20% change in at least one of the four ion concentrations are identified. The flux change of each of these metabolic reactions is shown in Figure 7, while the metabolic reactions are listed in Table 1 or Table 3. Since the flux change is not that large, the flux of each of these metabolic reactions for each iron concentration is normalized by its value for the reference ion concentration for a better illustration.
Upon the change in the availability of ferrous ion, Figure 7(a) shows that three of the metabolic reactions with large flux change (i.e., Rxn 1, Rxn 7, and Rxn 12) are involved in the arginine metabolism, while the other two reactions are related to acetate metabolism (i.e., Rxn 11) and the production of carbon dioxide (i.e., Rxn 13). Consistent with the biofilm formation profile shown in Figure 4(b), the selected five metabolic reactions have the largest flux change for the low iron concentration. The fluxes decrease and then increase when increasing iron to the medium, high, and very high concentrations. The reactions with large flux change upon the change in the sulfate availability (Figure 7(b)) are mainly involved in magnesium transport (Rxn 14), ammonia production (Rxn 3), tyrosine metabolism (Rxn 11), TCA cycle (Rxn 15 and Rxn 16), and arginine metabolism (Rxn 1). The overestimated biofilm formation for the low sulfate concentrations (shown in Figure 5(b)) is mainly due to the large increase in the fluxes through the exchange reactions for magnesium and citrate, which means that a low sulfate concentration in the medium promotes the exchange of magnesium and citrate which in turn facilitate the biofilm formation. As shown in Figure 7(c), the predicted increased biofilm formation for very low and high phosphate concentrations, which are the major discrepancies between the model prediction and experimental data shown in Figure 6(b), was mainly due to the large flux increase through the biofilm-associated reactions that were involved in the glutamate production (Rxn 6), acetate metabolism (Rxn 11), and arginine metabolism (Rxn 1 and Rxn 4). The enzymes that catalyze these metabolic reactions may need additional regulation for the very low or high phosphate concentration. Further investigation should be focused on the identification of phosphate-regulating signal transduction pathways that regulate these metabolic reactions.
Biofilms are often associated with human diseases, as they can protect pathogens from antibiotics. In addition, it is difficult to eliminate pathogens once they form a biofilm. This work presents the first systemic approach to quantify the ability of P. aeruginosa to form a biofilm upon varying the availability of amino acids, iron, sulfate, and phosphate in the medium, using both modeling and experimental approaches. Existing experimental data for P. aeruginosa biofilm formation upon the addition of amino acids confirmed the model predicted results for the impact of amino acids on P. aeruginosa biofilm formation. The modeling approach was then used to further predict P. aeruginosa biofilm formation for the change of ferrous ions, sulfate, and phosphate concentrations in a large range. Experiment was performed to validate those model predictions. Our experimental data by themselves are of value to the biofilm research community as they quantify P. aeruginosa biofilm formation for both very low and high concentrations of ions, which were seldom investigated in those existing experimental data. Our modeling approach can predict the trend of P. aeruginosa biofilm formation for all four concentrations of ferrous ions and sulfate. Although our approach overestimates the biofilm formation for the low phosphate concentration, it still correctly captures the change of biofilm formation for the low and medium concentrations. In addition to qualitatively predict the trend of the biofilm formation, 75% of the model-predicted biofilm formation value falls within or close to the error bar of the experimental value. The major discrepancies between model prediction and experimental data are found in the underestimation of biofilm formation for the starved ferrous ion concentration (i.e., 0.05-fold) and the overestimation for the starved and rich phosphate concentrations (i.e., 0.05- and 5-fold). The biofilm formation is a complicated process in which the bacteria regulate their metabolism upon the surrounding environmental conditions by down- or upregulating the enzymes that catalyze certain metabolic reactions. This work is mainly based upon a metabolic model, which generally consists of metabolic reactions constrained by expression levels of metabolic genes or activation levels of enzymes. These genes or enzymes are regulated by biochemical reactions used by P. aeruginosa to sense the change in the environmental condition and then regulate intracellular enzymes. These biochemical reactions, which are even not completely known, construct signaling pathways, a different type of reaction networks from metabolic networks. In order to improve the model prediction for extreme conditions that are characterized by starved and rich ion concentrations, further research needs to conduct to identify all the signaling proteins involved in these signaling pathways, estimate all kinetic constants in the signaling pathway, and then integrate these pathways with the metabolic model for the ion starved and rich conditions. Nevertheless, the developed modeling approach provided very good prediction performance for all ions in their low and medium concentrations.
The flux change through the 39 biofilm-associated reactions was quantified for all concentrations in this work. Based on this, the reactions with large flux change upon the change of the availability of amino acids, iron, sulfate, and phosphate were identified. It was found that reactions involved in arginine metabolism have large flux changes upon the change of the availability of the aforementioned nutrient components. In addition to arginine metabolism, reactions for ammonia production, the conversion of 4-maleylacetoacetate to 4-fumarylacetoacetate, and the magnesium transport reaction were of large flux change upon the change of the availability of several nutrient components studied in this work. These reactions indicate how P. aeruginosa changes its metabolism for the biofilm formation in response to the change in the nutrient availability. Some of these reactions or metabolisms were implied by existing experimental data for their important role in regulating P. aeruginosa biofilm formation. For example, enhanced availability of arginine is reported to promote P. aeruginosa biofilm formation .
Pseudomonas aeruginosa was selected as a model species for the biofilm formation in this work because it is one of the most extensively studied gram-negative bacteria that cause chronic wound infections. While the developed approach was applied to study Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm formation, it can be generalized to other biofilm-associated pathogens. Specially, for each target pathogen, gene expression data obtained for the biofilm mode can be used to identify reactions that are positively associated with the biofilm formation. With the substitution of the biofilm-associated reactions and the metabolic model of Pseudomonas aeruginosa with those of the target pathogen, the developed approach can quantify the biofilm formation of the target pathogen upon the change in the availability of environmental nutrients.
Although the influence of a single nutrient component on P. aeruginosa biofilm formation was investigated in this work, the framework developed here can be used as a platform to study the impact of the combination of multiple nutrient components. Specifically, the uptake rates for multiple nutrient components can be changed simultaneously to obtain the flux change curve over all biofilm-associated reactions, which can in turn be used to quantify biofilm formation capability upon the change of the availability of multiple nutrient components. Although this is an interesting topic to study and of value for guiding experimental design, this work mainly focused on changing the availability of a single nutrient component in standard media, as this is what most of current experimental research is focusing on.
4. Materials and Methods
4.1. Experimental Design to Quantify the Biofilm Formation of P. aeruginosa upon Differential Availabilities of Ferrous Ions, Sulfate, and Phosphate
All biofilm experiments were conducted at 37°C using P. aeruginosa PA14. LB medium was used for growing cells, and M9 medium supplemented with 0.4% glucose was used for performing the biofilm assays. The concentrations of sulfate, ferrous ion, and phosphate in M9-glu medium (named as reference concentrations in the following text) are characterized by 1 mM MgSO4, 0.01 mM Fe (NH4)2(SO4)2, 49.3 mM Na2HPO4, and 22 mM KH2PO4, respectively. Overnight cultures from two independent colonies were diluted to an optical density at 600 nm of 0.05 in M9-glu medium containing various amounts (i.e., 0.05, 0.5, 1 and 5 times the reference concentration) of sulfate, ferrous, and phosphate concentration. The cell suspensions were then transferred to 96-well polystyrene plates, and the plates were incubated at 37°C for 24 h without shaking. Biofilm formation was measured by performing crystal violet assay as described earlier (refer to Lee et al., 2009 , for the detail). Total biofilm biomass (absorbance at OD540) was normalized by total cell mass (absorbance at OD600) to obtain values for normalized biofilm formation and each data point was averaged from 10 replicate wells (five wells per independent culture).
4.2. The Flux Balance Analysis (FBA)
Flux balance analysis is one of the most commonly used approaches to quantify microbial growth for specific nutrient conditions. The metabolic network developed by Oberhardt et al., 2010 , is used in this work. It consists of 1056 genes, 883 reactions, and 760 metabolites. Figure 8(a) lists a portion of metabolic reactions from the model, which is mathematically represented by the stoichiometric matrix S in Figure 8(b). The nutrient condition is specified by the lower and upper bounds (i.e., and in Figure 8(b)) of the exchange reactions for nutrient components. Large upper bounds are assigned for those nutrient components that are abundant in the surrounding environment. It is assumed in the flux balance analysis that bacteria try to grow as fast as possible from the available nutrients. Therefore, the biomass growth rate is maximized upon the constraints imposed by the mass balance and the lower/upper bounds of fluxes. This turns to a linear optimization problem where the maximal is determined from the feasible solution space (Figure 8(c)). The COBRA toolbox developed by Dr. Palsson’s group at UCSD is used in this work to perform the flux balance analysis .
4.3. The Approach to Quantify the Ability of Planktonic P. aeruginosa to Form Biofilms for the Nutrient Conditions with Different Availabilities of Amino Acids and Ions (i.e., Phosphate, Sulfate, and Ferrous)
The similarity in the shape and magnitude of the flux change curve (Figure 1(c)) were used by our previous approach  to cluster single mutants into different groups to identify the gene targets for eliminating planktonic P. aeruginosa before it forms a biofilm. However, no approach has been proposed to directly quantify biofilm formation capability of planktonic P. aeruginosa from the flux change curve, in which the flux changes of different biofilm-associated reactions are quite different. To address this, we will define a new criterion from the flux change curve to quantify the ability of P. aeruginosa to form a biofilm. In addition, we will formulate an approach to solve a problem that has not been systemically investigated, that is, how to quantify the influence of the availability of environmental nutrients (including amino acids and ions such as phosphate, sulfate, and ferrous ions) on P. aeruginosa biofilm formation. Our approach consists of the following steps.(i)Define the reference and changed nutrient conditions for changing the availability of amino acids, phosphate, and sulfate and in the medium. In the amino acid study, only one amino acid is added at a time to the medium to mimic a changed nutrient condition with different amino acid availability. The maximal uptake rate in FBA for each amino acid is determined from the literature (i.e., Oberhardt et al., 2008 ). Four different concentrations are studied for each of the three ions. The maximal uptake rate for each ion is determined by fitting the biomass growth rate to the experimental data, while the biofilm formation is then predicted from the model. In order to study the influence of phosphate, sulfate, and ferrous ions on biofilm formation, a large range of availability concentrations are investigated for each ion in order to capture the complete picture on how the starved and rich availabilities of these ions affect biofilm formation and the biomass growth rate of P. aeruginosa.(ii)Sample the fluxes of each biofilm-associated reaction for both the reference and changed nutrient conditions using the ACHR sampling approach from the COBRA toolbox . As shown in Figure 9, the mean value and the probability density function of the sampled fluxes are calculated for the reference nutrient condition (i.e., and ) and for the changed nutrient condition (i.e., and ). The change in the flux distribution of each biofilm-associated reaction upon the change of the nutrient condition, that is, , is quantified by where is a two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test in which the test result is equal to one/zero if the distribution is statistically/not different from .(iii)Use (2) to quantify biofilm formation in the defined nutrient condition: where the function is equal to one if the flux through the biofilm-associated reaction does not change its direction upon the change of the availability of nutrient component ; that is, is positive. The rationale behind this is that reaction is positively associated with biofilm formation and a changed flux direction means the trend to form biofilms reverses. indicates biofilm formation capability of P. aeruginosa upon the change of the availability of nutrient component . A value of that is significantly larger than one means that P. aeruginosa increase its biofilm formation once the availability of nutrient component is changed from the reference to the changed condition.
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.
Zhaobin Xu and Zuyi Huang contributed to the design and coordination of the study. Zhaobin Xu performed the computational implementations. Zuyi Huang supervised the computational aspects of the work. Sabina Islam performed the biofilm experiments. All authors contributed to the analysis of the results and the preparation of the paper.
- A. K. Seth, M. R. Geringer, S. J. Hong, K. P. Leung, T. A. Mustoe, and R. D. Galiano, “In vivo modeling of biofilm-infected wounds: a review,” Journal of Surgical Research, vol. 178, no. 1, pp. 330–338, 2012.
- M. Otto, “Staphylococcal infections: mechanisms of biofilm maturation and detachment as critical determinants of pathogenicity,” Annual Review of Medicine, vol. 64, pp. 175–188, 2013.
- J. E. Nett, “Future directions for anti-biofilm therapeutics targeting Candida,” Expert Review of Anti-Infective Therapy, vol. 12, no. 3, pp. 375–382, 2014.
- M. Müsken, S. Di Fiore, A. Dötsch, R. Fischer, and S. Häussler, “Genetic determinants of Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm establishment,” Microbiology, vol. 156, no. 2, pp. 431–441, 2010.
- Q. Wang and T. Zhang, “Review of mathematical models for biofilms,” Solid State Communications, vol. 150, no. 21-22, pp. 1009–1022, 2010.
- D. McCloskey, B. Ø. Palsson, and A. M. Feist, “Basic and applied uses of genome-scale metabolic network reconstructions of Escherichia coli,” Molecular systems biology, vol. 9, p. 661, 2013.
- M. A. Oberhardt, J. Puchałka, K. E. Fryer, V. A. P. Martins Dos Santos, and J. A. Papin, “Genome-scale metabolic network analysis of the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1,” Journal of Bacteriology, vol. 190, no. 8, pp. 2790–2803, 2008.
- G. Sigurdsson, R. M. T. Fleming, A. Heinken, and I. Thiele, “A systems biology approach to drug targets in pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm,” PLoS ONE, vol. 7, no. 4, Article ID e34337, 2012.
- Z. Xu, X. Fang, T. K. Wood, and Z. J. Huang, “A systems-level approach for investigating Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm formation,” PLoS ONE, vol. 8, no. 2, Article ID e57050, 2013.
- P. I. Watnick, K. J. Fullner, and R. Kolter, “A role for the mannose-sensitive hemagglutinin in biofilm formation by Vibrio cholerae El Tor,” Journal of Bacteriology, vol. 181, no. 11, pp. 3606–3609, 1999.
- R. D. Monds and G. A. O'Toole, “The developmental model of microbial biofilms: ten years of a paradigm up for review,” Trends in Microbiology, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 73–87, 2009.
- M. Klausen, A. Heydorn, P. Ragas et al., “Biofilm formation by Pseudomonas aeruginosa wild type, flagella and type IV pili mutants,” Molecular Microbiology, vol. 48, no. 6, pp. 1511–1524, 2003.
- R. D. Monds, P. D. Newell, R. H. Gross, and G. A. O'Toole, “Phosphate-dependent modulation of c-di-GMP levels regulates Pseudomonas fluorescens Pf0-1 biofilm formation by controlling secretion of the adhesin LapA,” Molecular Microbiology, vol. 63, no. 3, pp. 656–679, 2007.
- E. Banin, M. L. Vasil, and E. P. Greenberg, “Iron and Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm formation,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 102, no. 31, pp. 11076–11081, 2005.
- M. A. Oberhardt, J. B. Goldberg, M. Hogardt, and J. A. Papin, “Metabolic network analysis of Pseudomonas aeruginosa during chronic cystic fibrosis lung infection,” Journal of Bacteriology, vol. 192, no. 20, pp. 5534–5548, 2010.
- S. P. Bernier, D.-G. Ha, W. Khan, J. H. Merritt, and G. A. O'Toole, “Modulation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa surface-associated group behaviors by individual amino acids through c-di-GMP signaling,” Research in Microbiology, vol. 162, no. 7, pp. 680–688, 2011.
- J. Schellenberger, R. Que, R. M. T. Fleming et al., “Quantitative prediction of cellular metabolism with constraint-based models: the COBRA Toolbox v2.0,” Nature Protocols, vol. 6, no. 9, pp. 1290–1307, 2011.
- O. Kroukamp and G. M. Wolfaardt, “CO2 production as an indicator of biofilm metabolism,” Applied and Environmental Microbiology, vol. 75, no. 13, pp. 4391–4397, 2009.
- E. Banin, K. M. Brady, and E. P. Greenberg, “Chelator-induced dispersal and killing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa cells in a biofilm,” Applied and Environmental Microbiology, vol. 72, no. 3, pp. 2064–2069, 2006.
- P. K. Singh, M. R. Parsek, E. P. Greenberg, and M. J. Welsh, “A component of innate immunity prevents bacterial biofilm development,” Nature, vol. 417, no. 6888, pp. 552–555, 2002.
- D. D. Sriramulu, H. Lünsdorf, J. S. Lam, and U. Römling, “Microcolony formation: a novel biofilm model of Pseudomonas aeruginosa for the cystic fibrosis lung,” Journal of Medical Microbiology, vol. 54, no. 7, pp. 667–676, 2005.
- D. J. Musk, D. A. Banko, and P. J. Hergenrother, “Iron salts perturb biofilm formation and disrupt existing biofilms of Pseudomonas aeruginosa,” Chemistry and Biology, vol. 12, no. 7, pp. 789–796, 2005.
- L. Yang, K. B. Barken, M. E. Skindersoe, A. B. Christensen, M. Givskov, and T. Tolker-Nielsen, “Effects of iron on DNA release and biofilm development by Pseudomonas aeruginosa,” Microbiology, vol. 153, no. 5, pp. 1318–1328, 2007.
- A. Zaborin, K. Romanowski, S. Gerdes et al., “Red death in Caenorhabditis elegans caused by Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 106, no. 15, pp. 6327–6332, 2009.
- J. Long, O. Zaborina, C. Holbrook, A. Zaborin, and J. Alverdy, “Depletion of intestinal phosphate after operative injury activates the virulence of P aeruginosa causing lethal gut-derived sepsis,” Surgery, vol. 144, no. 2, pp. 189–197, 2008.
- J. Lee, C. Attila, S. L. G. Cirillo, J. D. Cirillo, and T. K. Wood, “Indole and 7-hydroxyindole diminish Pseudomonas aeruginosa virulence,” Microbial Biotechnology, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 75–90, 2009.
Copyright © 2015 Zhaobin Xu et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.