Table 4: Summary of analysis.

Content analysisQ1Q2Q3Q4

No evidence that the student read/understood others’ ideas/contributions56%44%54%34%
Responding to others contribution by elaboration/critique or building-up15%21%31%36%
Evidence of good analysis of the case study data32%41%39%44%
Evidence of using and citing other sources/references in the response 17%18%21%24%
Demonstrable understanding of the questions and identification of issues in case study21%27%33%39%
Effective written communication64%72%56%71%
Evidence of pooling different ideas, expertise, and information in the development of an artifact
(related to question 3 only)