|
Study | Treatment group | CF sensing catheter/Agilis sheath | STSF catheter/Agilis sheath | Mapping system | Anterior/Posterior wall power | Local lesion endpoint | Ablation strategy |
|
Leo et al. [11] | HPSD-LSI 1 | +/+ | − | EnSite | 40 W | Target LSI of 5.5–6 at the LA anterior wall and 4 at the posterior wall | PVI ± line |
LPLD-LSI 1 | +/+ | − | EnSite | 40 W/20 W | Target LSI of 5.5–6 at the LA anterior wall and 4 at the posterior wall | PVI ± line |
HPSD-LSI 2 | +/+ | − | EnSite | 40 W | Target LSI of 5.5–6 at the LA anterior wall and 5 at the posterior wall | PVI ± line |
LPLD-LSI 2 | +/+ | − | EnSite | 40 W/20 W | Target LSI of 5.5–6 at the LA anterior wall and 5 at the posterior wall | PVI ± line |
|
Kaneshiro et al. [19] | HPSD-AI | − | +/− | CARTO | 45–50 W | Target AI of 400 at the LA posterior wall | PVI ± line |
LPLD | +−/− | +−/− | CARTO | 20–30 W | Duration at 10–30 s, CF 20–30 g | PVI ± line |
|
Berte et al. [17] | HPSD-AI | − | +/+ | CARTO | 45 W/35 W | Target AI of 550 at the LA anterior wall and 300–400 at the posterior wall | PVI |
LPLD-AI | − | +/+ | CARTO | 35 W/25 W | Target AI of 550 at the LA anterior wall and 300–400 at the posterior wall | PVI |
|
Okamatsu et al. [12] | HPSD-AI1 | − | +/+− | CARTO | 50 W/30–40 W | Target AI of 400 at the LA anterior wall and 260–360 at the posterior wall | PVI ± line ± box isolation ± CFAE |
LPLD-AI | − | +/+− | CARTO | 30 W/20 W | Target AI of 400 at the LA anterior wall and 260–360 at the posterior wall | PVI ± line ± box isolation ± CFAE |
HPSD-AI2 | − | +/+− | CARTO | 40 W/30 W | Target AI of 400 at the LA anterior wall and 260–360 at the posterior wall | PVI ± line ± box isolation ± CFAE |
|
Castrejon-Castrejon et al. [18] | HPSD50w-AI or LSI | +/+− | − | CARTO/ EnSite | 50 W | LSI≥ 5, AI≥ 350 at the LA posterior wall and ≥450 in others | PVI ± line |
HPSD60w | +/+− | − | CARTO/EnSite | 60 W | 2–7 s | PVI ± line |
LPLD | +/+− | − | CARTO/EnSite | 30 W/20–30 W | 30–60 s | PVI ± line |
|
Kyriakopoulou et al. [13] | HPSD-AI | +/− | − | CARTO | 40 W | Target AI of 550 at the LA anterior wall and 300–400 at the posterior wall | PVI |
LPLD-AI | +/− | − | CARTO | 35 W | Target AI of 550 at the LA anterior wall and 300–400 at the posterior wall | PVI |
|
Dhillon et al. [10] | HPSD-AI | − | +/− | CARTO | 40 W/30 W | Target AI of 450 at the LA anterior wall and 350 at the posterior wall | PVI ± line |
LPLD | +/− | − | CARTO | 30 W/25 W | CF 20–30 g | PVI ± line |
|