Research Article

Selection of Sustainable Supplementary Concrete Materials Using OSM-AHP-TOPSIS Approach

Table 1

Sustainability indicators along with subcriteria for selection of supplementary concrete materials.

CriteriaSubcriteria

Technical (C1)Support to concrete curing system (C11)
Support to concrete compaction system (C12)
Support to cohesiveness of concrete mix (C13)
Support to consistency of concrete mix (C14)
Comply strength requirement of concrete mix (C15)
Comply durability requirements of concrete mix (C16)
Relative proportion of concrete components (C17)
Supplementary material availability (C18)

Environmental (C2)Energy conservation (C21)
Concrete material conservation (C22)
Waste material utilization (C23)
Conformation to environmental standards (C24)
Reduction in carbon foot print (C25)
Resistance to extreme exposure conditions (C26)

Social (C3)Waste material cleaning (C31)
Public welfare and safety (C32)
Increased employment (C33)

Economic (C4)Concrete production cost (C41)
Supplementary material transportation cost (C42)
Life-long maintenance cost (C43)