Research Article

A Cross-National Study of Students’ Understanding of Genetics Concepts: Implications from Similarities and Differences in England and Turkey

Table 3

Students’ alternative conceptions displayed in their understanding of fundamental genetics concepts.

Alternative conceptionsEnglandTurkey
%%

Gene concept
Genes that determine an individual’s inherited characteristics are only found in sex cells. (Item (2))1627
The gene for eye colour is located in the iris because iris is the part of the eye responsible for eye colour. (Item (5))(5)17
The X and Y chromosomes, which are found in a sperm cell, carry all the genes. (Item (5))(6)17

Chromosome concept
Sex chromosomes are only found in sex cells. (Item (8))1011
The chromosomes, which determine the sex of an organism, are located only in the sex cells because a sperm cell can carry X or Y chromosomes and an egg cell can carry only X chromosome. (Item (8))2836

Relationships among gene, chromosome, and DNA
DNA is made of chromosomes. (Item (1))(5)19
Chromosomes make up genes. (Item (2))(9)15
Chromosomes form DNA. (Items (4))2525
Gene contains chromosomes and DNA. (Item (10))(6)11

Relationships between cell divisions and inheritance
Sperm cells of an organism have identical genes. (Item (7))1527
Somatic cells of an individual have different genes. (Item (10))1412
If the somatic cells did not undergo mitosis, the number of their chromosomes would be doubled. (Item (11))10(7)
Zygote undergoes meiosis for reducing its number of chromosomes to half. (Item (12))11(8)
Sex cells form a zygote by the process of meiosis. (Item (12))(7)18
Inherited characteristics are carried only by sex chromosomes. (Items (2) and (13))2326
Parent’s genes are transferred to the offspring by sex chromosomes of the father and the mother at fertilisation. (Item (13))2117