Comprehensive Evaluation of Salt Tolerance in Asparagus Germplasm Accessions (Asparagus officinalis L.) at Different Growth Stages

Table 1

Name, origin, and the salt tolerance grades of the 95 asparagus accessions at each growth stage.

Number	Name	Origin	Germination stage		Seedling stage		Adult stage
			RSR (%)	Grade	SI (%)	Grade	MVFS	Grade
1	Apllo	The United States	23.43	2	41.5	3	0.76	1
2	UC115	The United States	18.34	1	57.6	3	0.65	2
3	UC157	The United States	11.24	1	53.5	3	0.52	3
4	UC800	The United States	83.44	5	66.5	4	0.36	3
5	NJ800	The United States	27.07	2	56.5	3	0.76	1
6	NJ857	The United States	13.03	1	26.5	2	0.60	3
7	NJ951	The United States	50.87	3	67.8	4	0.55	3
8	NJ956	The United States	81.16	5	51.8	3	0.30	4
9	NJ978	The United States	71.07	4	78.6	4	0.41	3
10	NJ1089	The United States	8.85	1	68.2	4	0.36	3
11	NJ1123	The United States	83.61	5	38.5	2	0.29	4
12	NJ1156	The United States	42.49	3	78.8	4	0.63	2
13	NJ1189	The United States	23.55	2	62.5	4	0.55	3
14	NJ1191	The United States	41.72	3	63.8	4	0.65	2
15	Grande	The United States	22.46	2	71.8	4	0.59	3
16	Walker pioneer	The United States	40.04	3	66.7	4	0.65	2
17	Walker deluxe	The United States	63.50	4	39.2	2	0.48	3
18	Purple passion	The United States	53.38	3	68.9	4	0.46	3
19	Trillon	The United States	66.01	4	28.5	2	0.58	3
20	Patron	The United States	37.79	2	60.1	4	0.48	3
21	Jersey night	The United States	20.99	2	12.8	1	0.61	3
22	Jersey supreme	The United States	51.61	3	70.8	4	0.44	3
23	Jersey giant	The United States	37.51	2	72.5	4	0.45	3
24	Jersey knight	The United States	42.50	3	61.2	4	0.37	3
25	Male crown	The United States	28.69	2	42.7	3	0.52	3
26	Atlas	The United States	13.30	1	68.7	4	0.68	2
27	Florida	The United States	83.76	5	47.9	3	0.40	3
28	Early Califomia	The United States	94.20	5	59.2	3	0.63	2
29	Imperial	The United States	74.71	4	99.2	5	0.52	3
30	Wb-210	The United States	43.93	3	67.1	4	0.49	3
31	WB-215	The United States	52.65	3	77.6	4	0.49	3
32	Ariane	Germany	58.33	3	69.2	4	0.20	5
33	Eposs	Germany	35.66	2	50.4	3	0.19	5
34	European man	Germany	30.32	2	62.5	4	0.39	3
35	Pacific purple	New Zealand	34.65	2	77.3	4	0.50	3
36	Pacific challenger	New Zealand	33.71	2	65.4	4	0.46	3
37	Taramec	New Zealand	54.16	3	38.9	2	0.29	4
38	Pacific green	New Zealand	14.66	1	43.9	3	0.52	3
39	JWC1	New Zealand	21.85	2	63.7	4	0.47	3
40	Pacific 2000	New Zealand	61.56	4	29.5	2	0.36	3
41	Vittorio	Italy	53.98	3	81.6	5	0.28	4
42	Fo5030115	Italy	57.75	3	33.5	2	0.31	4
43	Fo5030215	Italy	31.56	2	16.7	1	0.60	3
44	Italo	Italy	10.59	1	64.1	4	0.48	3
45	Enos	Italy	64.48	4	74.8	4	0.51	3
46	Franklim	Holland	48.36	3	87.5	5	0.65	2
47	Gynlim	Holland	29.27	2	70.8	4	0.48	3
48	Boolim	Holland	73.14	4	38.9	2	0.47	3
49	Gijnlim	Holland	55.80	3	45.6	3	0.26	4
50	Limbras 10	Holland	37.25	2	67.2	4	0.52	3
51	Thielim	Holland	67.93	4	82.9	5	0.41	3
52	Taramea	Holland	34.92	2	61.4	4	0.41	3
53	James	Holland	52.00	3	51.3	3	0.26	4
54	Diamonds	Holland	53.45	3	97.2	5	0.26	4
55	Crown 300	Holland	41.83	3	73.6	4	0.55	3
56	Granno	Holland	33.26	2	15.2	1	0.43	3
57	Welcom	Japan	57.53	3	63.5	4	0.69	2
58	Accell	Japan	67.22	4	33.8	2	0.38	3
59	Shower	Japan	67.24	4	68.4	4	0.45	3
60	Mondeo	The United Kingdom	62.97	4	18.9	1	0.39	3
61	Shuofeng	China	56.01	3	72.5	4	0.44	3
62	Zhefeng-4112	China	63.93	4	58.8	3	0.20	5
63	Jiahui	China	67.85	4	49.6	3	0.19	5
64	Prince	China	83.40	5	42.6	3	0.34	3
65	Shengju-1	China	92.28	5	69.2	4	0.36	3
66	Sheng96-8	China	81.18	5	55.1	3	0.35	3
67	A11	China	64.14	4	67.2	4	0.43	3
68	Ji08-2	China	4.17	1	0	1	0.85	1
69	Jilulvwang	China	47.23	3	66.5	4	0.41	3
70	Jinggang red	China	73.20	4	46.6	3	0.65	2
71	Jinggang-701	China	61.45	4	26.6	2	0.53	3
72	Jing lv-1	China	45.47	3	52.4	3	0.32	3
73	Jing lv-2	China	47.18	3	62.8	4	0.33	3
74	Jing lv-3	China	50.42	3	91.2	5	0.26	4
75	Jing lv-1042	China	70.59	4	45.8	3	0.64	2
76	Jing lv-1040	China	76.35	4	86.4	5	0.45	3
77	Wei2014-1	China	73.23	4	58.9	3	0.36	3
78	Wei2014-2	China	67.95	4	95.8	5	0.38	3
79	TC	China	44.21	3	32.6	2	0.80	1
80	Green spears	China	71.86	4	98.5	5	0.44	3
81	Lu asp-1	China	33.65	2	43.8	3	0.54	3
82	Green foison	China	48.09	3	55.3	3	0.63	2
83	Lu2000-3	China	55.59	3	64.6	4	0.45	3
84	Jx1502	China	4.39	1	21.8	2	0.82	1
85	Gold crown	China	69.48	4	83.6	5	0.59	3
86	Jadeite Pearl	China	56.34	3	43.8	3	0.30	4
87	New2030	China	44.16	3	65.1	4	0.47	3
88	Champion	China	54.80	3	23.6	2	0.77	1
89	JK113	China	50.76	3	87.5	5	0.31	4
90	JK1125	China	14.60	1	57.6	3	0.32	3
91	BJ14001	China	35.79	2	48.6	3	0.36	3
92	BJ14003	China	68.03	4	52.8	3	0.43	3
93	BJ14004	China	70.18	4	70.9	4	0.37	3
94	BJ14006	China	61.02	4	68.5	4	0.46	3
95	C9-12	China	51.55	3	38.5	2	0.77	1

1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 in the last three columns represent the germplasm accessions of highly salt-tolerant, salt-tolerant, moderately salt-tolerant, salt-sensitive, and highly salt-sensitive, respectively. RSR: the relative salt-injury rate; SI: the salt-injury index; MFVS: the membership function value of salt tolerance.