Research Article | Open Access
Design Space Approach in Optimization of Fluid Bed Granulation and Tablets Compression Process
The aim of this study was to optimize fluid bed granulation and tablets compression processes using design space approach. Type of diluent, binder concentration, temperature during mixing, granulation and drying, spray rate, and atomization pressure were recognized as critical formulation and process parameters. They were varied in the first set of experiments in order to estimate their influences on critical quality attributes, that is, granules characteristics (size distribution, flowability, bulk density, tapped density, Carr's index, Hausner's ratio, and moisture content) using Plackett-Burman experimental design. Type of diluent and atomization pressure were selected as the most important parameters. In the second set of experiments, design space for process parameters (atomization pressure and compression force) and its influence on tablets characteristics was developed. Percent of paracetamol released and tablets hardness were determined as critical quality attributes. Artificial neural networks (ANNs) were applied in order to determine design space. ANNs models showed that atomization pressure influences mostly on the dissolution profile, whereas compression force affects mainly the tablets hardness. Based on the obtained ANNs models, it is possible to predict tablet hardness and paracetamol release profile for any combination of analyzed factors.
1.1. Quality by Design (QbD)
Recently proposed quality-by-design (QbD) regulatory initiative of pharmaceutical product and process development has encouraged researchers in pharmaceutical industry to reach the “desired state” of drug manufacturing in 21st century. Main goal of this approach is to gain a comprehensive understanding of their manufacturing processes, with an accurate estimation of their robustness and reliability. The emphasis has changed from the need to demonstrate that the product will consistently meet relatively tight specifications to a new situation of being able to demonstrate that the product is controlled within a broader “design space” (DS). The design space (DS) concept is introduced as “the multidimensional combination and interaction of input variables (e.g., materials attributes) and process parameters that have been demonstrated to provide assurance of quality.” Using this approach, it is essential to define relationship between critical formulation/process parameters and critical quality attributes (such as granule characteristics and tablet properties) [1, 2].
1.2. Fluid Bed Granulation
Wet granulation is a process of small particles agglomeration into larger, relatively permanent structures in which the original particles can still be identified . In fluid bed granulation process, binder solution is usually sprayed in form of the fine droplets onto powder mass in state of fluidization. It is a very complex process influenced by many factors. These factors are classified into three groups: formulation factors, process parameters, and equipment related factors. Their numerous interactions make the process optimization much more difficult .
The influence of process parameters and formulation factors on the fluid bed granulation process has been studied extensively in the last few years. The most widely studied formulation factors are type of diluent and binder and concentration of the binder solution. The previous studies proved that, when hydrophilic diluents were used, large-size granules were obtained. This is a result of better wetting of powder mass and consequently faster granules growth [4, 5]. An increase in the binder concentration decreases duration of granulation [6–8]. Higher values of Carr’s index and Hausner’s ratio, which point to poor flowability, are recorded when higher binder concentration was used [8, 9]. The most extensively studied process parameters are atomization pressure, air flow rate, temperature and humidity of inlet air, and spray rate. It has been shown that increase in the atomization pressure leads to decrease in the binder droplet size [7, 10]. In most studies [9–12], granules size increased with decrease in atomization pressure. Small-size granules were obtained when high air flow rate was used, because of the more intensive breakage and faster evaporation of binder solution [7, 11–13]. Increase in the spray rate leads to the increase in granules size because of the larger droplet size, improved powder mass wetting, and formation of more bonds between the particles [7, 13, 14]. The decrease in granule size was recorded with higher inlet air temperature, because of the faster binder evaporation . Inlet air humidity has the opposite effect; increase in this parameter leads to the increase in granules size as well .
1.3. Artificial Neural Networks
Artificial neural networks (ANNs) are computer programs designed to simulate some of the human brain functions such as learning, ability to generalize, and draw conclusions from the gained experience. Application of artificial neural networks is a new dimension in the formulation of drugs because of the unique advantages such as nonlinearity, the ability of modeling and optimization with a small set of experiments. ANNs are not programmed, they learn from the presented solved problems. Using different algorithms for learning, they recognize the relationships and patterns within the data presented to them and thus acquire the ability to predict responses to new experimental conditions. The ability of neural networks to generalize the problem is one of the strongest motivations for research in this area .
The way in which the neurons are interconnected is referred to as a “network architecture” or “topology.” A variety of network architectures has been developed for different applications, but one of the most common is a multilayer perceptron (MLP) network (Figure 1) in which the neurons are organized into layers. The first layer is called the input layer and has no ability to generate the data. It serves for the transmission of input values to the first hidden layer. The inputs are simply the input variables, such as ingredients, ingredient amounts, and processing conditions. The last layer is used to process the output values of the dependent variables such as in vitro drug release profile and is called the output layer. Between these two layers, there are hidden layers that are used to enable connections between the input and output layers. The complexity of the problem determines the number of the hidden layer neurons. This is a “feed forward” network, which means that information is passed in one direction through the network from the inputs, through various hidden layers to the outputs. If set of inputs variables is provided, the ANNs model can be used to predict the response such as critical quality attribute of the product. Well-trained models can answer the questions like “what if ?” or “what kind of re lease profile can be expected with changing excipients concentration?” . Artificial neural networks can be successfully used in pharmaceutical formulations optimization [17–22].
The aim of our study was to define the design space of fluid bed granulation and tablet compression process. In the first part, the assessment of process and formulation factors (critical material and process parameters) and their influence on granules characteristics (critical quality attributes) was performed. Optimal variables values from the first set of experiments were used in the second set, while atomization pressure and compression force were varied, in order to develop new design space, evaluating their influence on tablets characteristics.
2. Materials and Methods
Materials used in the presented study for the granulation and tabletting experiments were: paracetamol (Ph.Eur. 7.0), polyethylene oxide (Polyox WSR Coagulant, Dow Chemical, USA, USP30-NF25), anhydrous lactose (Ph.Eur. 7.0), microcrystalline cellulose (Vivapur Type 101, J. Rettenmaier & Söhne GmbH, Germany, Ph.Eur. 7.0), and purified water (Aqua purificata, Ph.Eur. 7.0).
2.2. Wet Granulation Process
The granulation was performed in the fluid bed granulator Mycrolab (Hüttlin, Germany). Diluent type, binder (polyethylene-oxide) concentration, temperature during mixing and granulation, air flow rate during mixing, granulation and drying, spray rate, and atomization pressure were varied on two levels (Table 1). Anhydrous lactose or microcrystalline cellulose was used as diluent. Polyethylene-oxide was used as a binder, whereas purified water was used as the binder solvent. For each experimental run, 250 g of granules were prepared, with the granules composition and the processing parameters being given by the number of experimental run, as represented in Table 3. Paracetamol was included in formulations in the second set of experiments. Paracetamol was selected as a highly water-soluble model drug, in order to investigate the possibility to obtain its modified release by using polyethylene oxide polymer as the granules binder. Powder mass was first mixed in the granulator for 5 min. After this, water was sprayed onto the powder mass (containing diluent and polyethylene-oxide) from the bottom of the chamber in the half amount of powder mass. The granulation phase lasted until the whole amount of water was spent. Then, when the product temperature started to rise, the inlet air temperature was set on 0°C in order to cool the product.
2.3. Design of Experiments
Plackett-Burman experimental design was used to investigate the influence of formulation and process variables on the granules and tablets characteristics. Coded variables values are given in the Table 2. Experimental plan was obtained after replacing coded with real variables values (Table 3). The result of each experiment is a linear combination of variables effects: As eight experiments were performed, the system of eight linear equations was obtained. Coefficients β1,β2,…,β7 show how much each of the seven variables influences on granules characteristics. Their values were calculated using Design Expert software (Stat-Ease, USA).
|X1: type of diluent.|
X2: binder (polyethylene-oxide) concentration (%).
X3: temperature during mixing and granulation ().
X4: air flow rate during mixing (m3/h).
X5: air flow rate during drying (m3/h).
X6: spray rate (g/min).
X7: atomization pressure (bar).
2.4. Granules Characterization
2.4.1. Granules Size Distribution
Granules size distribution was determined by the sieve analysis method . A 100-g granule sample was transferred to the set of sieves (180, 315, and 500 μm size) and shaken for 10 min. After 10 minutes of sieving, the fractions of granules retained on each sieve were weighed and these weights were converted into mass percentages.
Granules flowability was determined by the official method . A 50 g sample of granules was transferred to the flow testing device (Flow meter GDT, Erweka, Germany), and the time needed for sample flowing through an orifice of 12 mm in diameter was measured. The flowability was expressed as a flow rate which was calculated from the ratio of sample mass and measured time. Results are expressed as the mean value of three replicates.
2.4.3. Bulk Density
Bulk density was determined in the graduated 50 mL cylinder. 15 g of sample was measured and poured into cylinder. The bulk density was calculated as the ratio of granules mass and read volume.
2.4.4. Tapped Density
After determination of the bulk density, graduated cylinder was exposed to agitation and mild striking to the solid surface. The number of taps varied depending on the differences in the granules volume after agitation. Once the volume did not change significantly, striking was stopped. The number of taps did not exceed 100. Tapped density was calculated as the ratio of granules mass and read volume after agitation.
2.4.5. Hausner’s Ratio
Hausner’s ratio was calculated using the formula: (see ).
2.4.6. Carr’s Ratio
Carr’s ratio was calculated using the formula (see ).
2.4.7. Moisture Content
The granules moisture content was determined gravimetrically on a Chyo 91 device (Chyo, USA). A certain sample mass was transferred to the device, and after 30 min of warming with the lamp at 105°C, the moisture content was read from the display.
2.5. Tablets Preparation
Fluid bed granulation and tabletting of obtained granules on eccentric tablet machine was performed in the second set of experiments. Optimal values of formulation and process factors (X1–X6, Table 1.) were defined by analyzing their influence on granules characteristics in the first set of experiments. Atomization pressure (X7, Table 1) and tablet compression force were varied on three levels in the second set of experiments. Nine formulations (Ft1–Ft9, Table 4) were prepared. The mass of tablets was 500 mg each, while the paracetamol content was 100 mg per tablet.
2.6. Tablets Characterization
2.6.1. Resistance to the Crushing of Tablets
This test is intended to determine, under defined conditions, the resistance to crushing of tablets, measured by the force needed to disrupt them by crushing. Resistance to crushing of tablets was determined on Erweka TB24 (Erweka, Germany), measuring the force that leads to the tablet fracture. Results are expressed as the mean value of 10 replicates.
2.6.2. Dissolution Testing
Dissolution testing was performed in the rotating paddle apparatus (Erweka DT70, Germany). Phosphate buffer (, USP30-NF25) in the volume of 900 mL was used as a medium, and the rotating paddle speed was 50 rpm. Medium temperature was maintained on 37°C to simulate physiological conditions. Sampling was carried out at 5, 10, 20, 30, 45, 60, 90, 120, 150, and 180 minutes, and the absorbance of paracetamol was measured at 243 nm by the UV/VIS spectrophotometer Evolution 300 (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Cambridge, UK). Results are expressed as the mean value of three replicates.
2.6.3. Analysis of Results Using Artificial Neural Networks
Inform® software (Intelligensys, UK) was used to analyze the results of the second set of experiments. The input parameters (independent variables) were atomization pressure and compression force. Tablets hardness and percentage of paracetamol released after 5, 10, 20, 30, 45, 60, 90, 150 and 180 minutes were determined as outputs (dependent variables). ANN used in the study was of the multilayer perceptron (MLP) type with the backpropagation learning algorithm.
3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Influence of the Formulation and Process Parameters on Granules Characteristics
Characterization of obtained granules was performed after granulation. Granules size distribution, flowability, bulk and tapped density, Hausner’s ratio, Carr’s index, and granules moisture content were determined as product characteristics. The results of the first set of experiments are given in the Table 5.
|Y1: granules size distribution (%).|
Y2: flowability (g/s).
Y3: bulk density (g/mL).
Y4: tapped density (g/mL).
Y5: Hausner’s ratio.
Y6: Carr’s index (%).
Y7: moisture content (%).
The aim was to obtain uniform granules of medium size. The target size was between 180 and 500 μm. Granules smaller than 180 μm tend to have greater cohesiveness, higher Hausner’s index, and lower compressibility. Therefore, high percent of this fraction is not desired. The purpose of granulation is to improve the flow properties of powder mix, so high flow rates are desired. As it can be seen from the Table 5, flow rates were very variable. Granules obtained from experiment three were not flowable. This experiment was not successful because the powder was overwetted. Earlier study  showed that combination oflow air flow rate, low inlet air temperature, and high spray rate, such as in this experiment, is associated with high risk of overwetting and defluidization. Also, hydrophobic substances such as microcrystalline cellulose are more susceptible to overwetting than hydrophilic ones like anhydrous lactose. Hausner’s ratio lower than 1.34 and Carr’s index lower than 25% were considered to be acceptable . Higher values that indicate poorer flowability and compressibility are recorded in experiments where granules smaller than 180 μm were obtained in high percentage (Table 5). The moisture content values less than 3.5% were considered to be acceptable. Except experiments 2 and 3, all experiments gave granules with acceptable moisture content.
The analysis of influence of formulation and process factors on granules properties is shown in the Table 6. The diluent type has the strongest influence on each examined characteristic. The fraction of granules with size between 180 and 500 μm increases when anhydrous lactose is selected as a diluent. Granules smaller than 180 μm were obtained in high percentage using microcrystalline cellulose as diluent. This is in concordance with earlier results, which showed that larger granules were obtained when hydrophilic diluents were used [5, 6]. Better flowability and lower moisture content also support the choice of anhydrous lactose as a diluent. The second significant factor is atomization pressure. Larger granules were obtained when lower atomization pressure was used in the process. The same results are recorded in earlier studies [9–12]. But, unexpectedly, granules flowability was not improved with decrease in the atomization pressure. This may be explained with higher moisture content at lower atomization pressure, which increases cohesiveness, and may decrease flowability. For better evaluation of the impact of atomization pressure, this parameter was varied on three levels in the second set of experiments. The temperature during mixing and granulation has the significant influence only on the Carr’s index and Hausner’s ratio. Higher values of these parameters, which indicate to poor flowability and compressibility, are recorded at higher temperature which is in agreement with earlier results . Other process parameters have less significant influence on granules properties. After analysis of factors influence on the granulation process, process and formulation variables that gave granules with desired properties were chosen: anhydrous lactose as a diluent, higher polyethylene-oxide concentration (10%), lower temperature during mixing and granulation (55°C), lower air flow rate during mixing and granulation (20 m3/h), lower air flow rate during drying (20 m3/h), higher spray rate (10 g/min). These values were used in the second set of experiments, while atomization pressure was varied on three levels.
3.2. Results of the Second Set of Experiments
3.2.1. Tablets Hardness Testing
Results of tablets hardness testing are given in the Table 7. According to results, tablets hardness is very variable, in the range of 3.68 N to 118.21 N, which could have influence on drug release and physical stability of tablets as well.
3.2.2. Drug Release Profiles from Tablets
Percentages of released paracetamol in different time intervals during 3 hours are given in Table 8. Dissolution profiles are very different (Figure 2). Formulations Ft1, Ft2, Ft4, and Ft7 showed immediate release (after 30 min, over 80% of paracetamol has been released), while formulations where atomization pressure during granulation was 1 bar showed modified release profiles. Percentage of released paracetamol after 30 min varied from 18.12% (Ft9) to 83.30% (Ft2).
|A.P.: atomization pressure.|
3.2.3. Analysis of the Influence of Atomization Pressure and Compression Force on Tablets Hardness Using ANNs
Using ANNs, it is possible to visualize dependent variables (tablets hardness and percentage of released paracetamol in different periods of time during 3 h) in function of independent variables (atomization pressure and compression force) by 3D diagrams. It is possible to predict responses in all points of experimental field, because the software finds “ideal” formulation, and further experiments are not necessary. Figure 3 shows changing of tablets hardness in function of independent variables (atomization pressure and compression force).
3D diagram from Figure 3 shows that atomization pressure has less influence on tablets hardness in comparison to the compression force used for tablet manufacturing. Also, increasing compression force, tablets hardness increased as well.
3.2.4. Analysis of the Influence of Atomization Pressure and Compression Force on Paracetamol Release from Tablets Using ANNs
Figure 4 presents 3D diagrams which describe the influence of compression force and atomization pressure on paracetamol release. It is clearly seen that both of parameters have influence on release profile, but the impact of atomization pressure is much stronger. The percent of released paracetamol decrease with increasing of atomization pressure and compression force. From obtained results, it may be concluded that high atomization pressure (1 bar) is a good way to achieve modified release of paracetamol from tablets, while increasing of compression force may further support this aim.
The main advantage of these models is the possibility to predict drug release and tablets hardness for any combination of atomization pressure and compression force in each point of experimental field. Figure 5 shows the contour plot describing the influence of atomization pressure and compression force on the percent of paracetamol released after 30 min. It is obvious, that, in wide range of process parameters, the percent of released paracetamol is less than 80%. This shows that polyethylene-oxide delayed release of active substance, which is its purpose in hydrophilic matrix systems.
3.2.5. Predicting Independent Variables (Compression Force and Atomization Pressure) Based on Desired Values of Tablet Hardness and Percentage of Released Paracetamol in Different Time Periods during 3 h Using ANNs
Besides potentially predicting output parameters, it is possible to predict input parameters based on assigned output parameters. First, the information of desired output parameters is being given to the network, and then the network defines their real values and predicts optimal values of input parameters.
The range between minimum and maximum values of desired output parameters is shown in the Table 9. Based on these desired values, defined by the user, network predicts optimal values. In the end, ANN provides the optimal values of input parameters for achieving the desired outputs as in this case atomization pressure of 1 bar and tabletting compression force of 3.66 kN.
Based on obtained ANNs models, it is possible to predict tablet hardness and released profile of paracetamol for any combination of analyzed factors. This defines design space for fluid bed wet granulation process with paracetamol as an active substance, polyethylene-oxide as a binder, and also design space of obtained granules tabletting process. Quality-by-design approach provides complete knowledge of the process, process control, and observing the principles that “the quality is not being tested, it is built into the product.”
With the development of new user-friendly software package, the growing use of ANNs in design and development of new medicinal preparations is expected. This will also enable the quick and easy evaluation of stability, safety, and efficacy of drugs, with greatly costs reducing.
- International Conference on Harmonization (ICH) of Technical Requirements for Registration of Pharmaceuticals for Human Use, Topic Q8(R2): P harm. Dev. Geneva, 2009.
- L. X. Yu, “Pharmaceutical quality by design: product and process development, understanding, and control,” Pharmaceutical Research, vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 781–791, 2008.
- D. M. Parikh, Handbook of Pharmaceutical Granulation Technology, Taylor & Francis Group, New York, NY, USA, 2nd edition, 2005.
- A. Faure, P. York, and R. C. Rowe, “Process control and scale-up of pharmaceutical wet granulation processes: a review,” European Journal of Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics, vol. 52, no. 3, pp. 269–277, 2001.
- J. Rantanen, A. Jørgensen, E. Räsänen et al., “Process analysis of fluidized bed granulation,” AAPS PharmSciTech, vol. 2, no. 4, p. 21, 2001.
- P. Rajniak, C. Mancinelli, R. T. Chern, F. Stepanek, L. Farber, and B. T. Hill, “Experimental study of wet granulation in fluidized bed: impact of the binder properties on the granule morphology,” International Journal of Pharmaceutics, vol. 334, no. 1-2, pp. 92–102, 2007.
- J. Bouffard, M. Kaster, and H. Dumont, “Influence of process variable and physicochemical properties on the granulation mechanism of mannitol in a fluid bed top spray granulator,” Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy, vol. 31, no. 9, pp. 923–933, 2005.
- T. B. Patel, L. D. Patel, T. B. Patel, S. H. Makwana, and T. R. Patel, “Influence of process variables on physicochemical properties of the granulation mechanism of diclofenac sodium in fluid bed granulation,” International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences Review and Research, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 61–65, 2010.
- I. Tomuţă, C. Alecu, L. L. Rus, and S. E. Leuçuta, “Optimization of fluid bed formulations of metoprolol granules and tablets using an experimental design Optimization of fluid bed formulations,” Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy, vol. 35, no. 9, pp. 1072–1081, 2009.
- H. Ehlers, J. Larjo, O. Antikainen, H. Räikkönen, J. Heinämäki, and J. Yliruusi, “In situ droplet size and speed determination in a fluid -bed granulator,” International Journal of Pharmaceutics, vol. 391, no. 1-2, pp. 148–154, 2010.
- B. Rambali, L. Baert, D. Thoné, and D. L. Massart, “Using experimental design to optimize the process parameters in fluidized bed granulation,” Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy, vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 47–55, 2001.
- S. S. Behzadi, J. Klocker, H. Hüttlin, P. Wolschann, and H. Viernstein, “Validation of fluid bed granulation utilizing artificial neural network,” International Journal of Pharmaceutics, vol. 291, no. 1-2, pp. 139–148, 2005.
- B. Rambali, L. Baert, and D. L. Massart, “Using experimental design to optimize the process parameters in fluidized bed granulation on a semi-full scale,” International Journal of Pharmaceutics, vol. 220, no. 1-2, pp. 149–160, 2001.
- T. Otsuka, Y. Iwao, A. Miyagishima, and S. Itai, “Application of principal component analysis enables to effectively find important physical variables for optimization of fluid bed granulator conditions,” International Journal of Pharmaceutics, vol. 409, no. 1-2, pp. 81–88, 2011.
- T. Lipsanen, O. Antikainen, H. Räikkönen, S. Airaksinen, and J. Yliruusi, “Novel description of a design space for fluidised bed granulation,” International Journal of Pharmaceutics, vol. 345, no. 1-2, pp. 101–107, 2007.
- J. Swabrick, Encyclopedia of Pharmaceutical Technology, Informa Healthcare USA, New York, NY, USA, 3rd edition, 2007.
- Y. Chen, T. W. McCall, A. R. Baichwal, and M. C. Meyer, “The application of an artificial neural network and pharmacokinetic simulations in the design of controlled-release dosage forms,” Journal of Controlled Release, vol. 59, no. 1, pp. 33–41, 1999.
- S. Ibrić, M. Jovanović, Z. Djurić, J. Parojčić, and L. Solomun, “The application of generalized regression neural network in the modeling and optimization of aspirin extended release tablets with Eudragit RS PO as matrix substance,” Journal of Controlled Release, vol. 82, no. 2-3, pp. 213–222, 2002.
- S. Ibrić, M. Jovanović, Z. Durić et al., “Artificial neural networks in the modeling and optimization of aspirin extended release tablets with Eudragit L 100 as matrix substance,” AAPS PharmSciTech, vol. 4, no. 1, p. E9, 2003.
- S. Ibrić, M. Jovanović, Z. Durić, J. Parojčić, L. J. Solomun, and B. Lučić, “Generalised regression neural networks in predicting of drug stability,” Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology, vol. 59, no. 5, pp. 745–750, 2007.
- T. Wu, W. Pan, J. Chen, and R. Zhang, “Formulation optimization technique based on artificial neural network in salbutamol sulfate osmotic pump tablets,” Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy, vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 211–215, 2000.
- K. Takayama, M. Fujikawa, Y. Obata, and M. Morishita, “Neural network based optimization of drug formulations,” Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews, vol. 55, no. 9, pp. 1217–1231, 2003.
- Council of Europe, European Pharmacopoeia, Council of Europe, Strasbourg, France, 7th edition, 2011.
Copyright © 2012 Jelena Djuriš et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.