Abstract

Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) is exponentially spreading across the world, leading to an outbreak of serious viral pneumonia. Antiviral therapies using chloroquine, hydroxychloroquine, and favipiravir have been approved by several countries to increase the quality of life of SARS-CoV-2-infected patients. Currently, several companies are intensively working on the production of coronavirus (CoV) vaccines, resulting in some specific vaccines that have been approved for CoV infections in humans. Nevertheless, efficient and specific prevention, treatment, and diagnosis are urgently required to combat the biological diversity and rapid mutation in CoV infections. Recently, significant attention has devoted to nanoformulation or nanoparticles (NPs) due to their specific features like high surface-to-volume ratio, drug encapsulation abilities, and specific optical properties to remove the complications of applied conventional therapeutic and diagnosis options. In this regard, NPs are increasingly used as new anti-CoV agents, vaccine carriers or adjuvants, and nanoscale biorecognition elements. The present review article provides a comprehensive discussion on the recent updates regarding the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of different CoV infections with an emphasis on the application of NPs in vaccination, treatment, and diagnosis of CoV infections.

1. Introduction

Infections with coronaviruses (CoVs) have been on top of the list of leading mortality causes in recent decades. In late 2019, a pandemic outbreak of a new CoV infection in humans, known as severe acute respiratory syndrome CoV-2 (SARSCoV-2) or COVID-19, has caused public anxiety [1]. Current antiviral therapies are fairly effective in the treatment of CoV infections [2, 3]. To date, some countries have approved some antiviral drugs as pharmacological treatment options for COVID-19. However, some approved COVID-19-specific vaccines are available. Several companies have developed various vaccine candidates for human CoV (HCoV) infections which are in the clinical trial stage [4]. Similar to other conventional therapeutic and diagnostic systems, CoV therapies and diagnostic systems also suffer from limitations in their efficient use in clinical situations to prevent, treat, and diagnose infections. The toxicity of antiviral drugs, low physicochemical stability of therapeutic agents, poor pharmacokinetics and bioavailability, low sensitivity, and high-cost and time-consuming methods have hindered the advance of novel formulations [5].

The nanotechnology-based formulations are the promising developing formulations which are benefited from eminent features such as high surface to volume ratio, easy surface modification, enhanced physicochemical stability, specific optical properties, and targeted and controlled release capabilities that can lead to lower toxicity and higher efficacy, making them more favorable for the effective prevention, treatment, and diagnosis of viral infections, especially CoV infections [6]. Currently, different nanoparticle-based antiviral agents (especially gold and polymeric NPs) have drawn the attention of scientists due to their specific optical and encapsulation properties for prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of various viral diseases like Ebola, influenza, HSV, and HIV [712]. Given the extensive abilities of nanotechnology, it is probable that novelties in this field could substantially influence the advances in combat against CoV-associated infections. In context, the current review is focused on the potential use of nanotechnology for the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of CoV infections. However, most of these studies are at primary steps but their outcomes are promising.

2. Coronaviruses

CoVs are mostly spherically shaped viruses with a diameter of around 60-140 nm. They contain a single-stranded positive-sense RNA genome as one of the largest genomes among RNA viruses [13]. CoVs are split into four separate generations including α-, β-, γ-, and δ-CoV [14]. α- and β-CoVs only infect mammals, while γ- and δ-CoVs can infect birds and some mammals. To date, seven CoVs such as CoV-OC43, CoV-229E, HCoV-OC43, CoV-HKU1, CoV-NL63, Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS)-CoV, and severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS)-CoV and SARS-CoV-2 or COVID-19 have been reported to cause infections in human [15, 16]. COVID-19 can result in severe upper respiratory infections similar to a common cold which can mostly lead to death in older people, mainly those with severe underlying health conditions compared to younger ones [17, 18]. The enveloped RNA genomes of CoVs encode three membrane proteins and nucleocapsid (N) protein associated with the RNA genome [19]. The membrane proteins consist of the large spike (S) glycoprotein which contains the receptor-binding domain (RBD) that has a significant role in receptor binding and virus entrance to cells. Since the M protein of SARS-CoV can induce neutralizing antibodies and N protein has T cell epitopes, they have attracted significant attention for vaccine developments [2022].

3. Conventional Prevention, Diagnosis, and Treatment of Coronavirus Infections

Combating viral infection is an enormous challenge in healthcare systems, primarily due to the challenges associated with the spread of viral infections as well as the potential capability of the virus to survive through mutations [23]. Currently, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the National Medical Products Administration of several countries have approved limited emergency use of antiviral drugs as a remedy for COVID-19 [24]. As can be seen in Table 1, many companies and institutes all over the world are working to develop HCoV vaccines. However, some approved specific vaccine treatments have been licensed for COVID-19, yet prevention measures (e.g., blocking the transmission routes such as the mouth and nose by a napkin, frequent washing of hands, and hand disinfection after presence in public places) are important strategies to combat CoVs. Besides, public transport, as well as eating or touching animals in places struggling with epidemics, should be avoided. Moreover, people should boost their immune system by the well-adjusted diet, sufficient exercise and rest, and maintaining their emotional and mental health. Patients should be isolated in specified hospitals and receive supportive treatments including bed rest, oxygen, calorie, and enough electrolytes in combination with drug treatments [16, 25]. The potential roles of nanotechnology in the prevention of CoV infections will be discussed in the succeeding sections.

On the other hand, given that the medication in the early stages of infection is closely linked to the effectiveness or success of treatment for CoV infections and the challenges in CoV infections detection from clinical symptoms, the production of rapid detection systems can significantly reduce the spread and morbidity of these infectious species [26]. Up to now, various diagnostic assays including protein microarray [27], enzyme-linked immunosorbent (ELISA), immunofluorescence [28], reverse transcription loop-mediated isothermal amplification (RT-LAMP) [29], and viral flow cytometry (FCM) [29] have been applied for fast and accurate diagnosis of coronavirus infections. Nevertheless, the determination of the genome sequences of coronaviruses, e.g., COVID-19, leads to the recognition of reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assays as a standard and highly sensitive technique for clinical diagnosis of COVID-19. The development of facile and quick assays is still a vital necessity [30, 31]. Since the RT-PCR method requires complicated machines, well-educated experts in molecular diagnostics, and specific laboratories, diagnostic kits have been designed by various research groups and companies to eliminate the RNA extraction and purification steps, resulting in rapid detection of CoV infections.

Currently, a broad range of pharmacological strategies, such as antivirals, and corticosteroid therapy, cell-based therapeutic options, and traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) have been applied to treat various CoV infections, as presented in Table 2. Recent antiretroviral therapy using HIV drugs has attracted increasing attention. Lopinavir/ritonavir, an HIV protease inhibitor, alone or in combination with other antiviral drugs or IFNα can contribute to the treatment of severe SARS-CoV or MERS-CoV patients [3234]. IFNα promotes the immune responses of infected patients and also interferes with virus replication [35, 36]. In addition to protease inhibitors, nucleoside analogs have shown significant potentials for CoV infection therapy. For example, ribavirin or tribavirin can be used in the treatment of SARS-CoV and MERS-CoV infections by preventing inosine monophosphate dehydrogenase activity, which can prevent the guanosine triphosphate (GTP) synthesis required for RNA and DNA replication of virus [37, 38]. Another nucleoside analog, favipiravir, which has also shown anti-SARS-CoV-2 activity, is the first approved coronavirus drug in China’s National Medical Products Administration [39]. The in vivo and in vitro anti-SARS and MERS activity of remdesivir, an Ebola drug, indicated that it can be used as a promising candidate for COVID-19 treatment [40]. Oseltamivir has been used for COVID-19 patients, but its efficacy should be further evaluated [16]. Altogether, despite the relative success of antiviral therapies in the treatment of CoV infections (especially in COVID-19), there are some concerns associated with their coadministration with other drugs as well as their potential side effects such as anemia, diarrhea, vomiting, and liver problems [41].

As pharmacological options, some medications used for the treatment of other diseases (e.g., malaria and arthritis) have recently gained increasing attention. Chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine have shown anti-SARS-CoV-2 activities and were recently approved by the FDA for limited emergency use against COVID-19 [42]. In fact, they inhibit the virus entry into the cells and hence blocking its transport into the cell organelles [43]. As another class of pharmacological options for treatment of CoV infections, corticosteroids have been applied to suppress cytokine production in SARS-CoV and MERS-CoV patients; nevertheless, there is no compelling evidence for its effectivity on COVID-19 treatment and some recommended its use for a short time [16, 44, 45].

According to Tables 1 and 2, in addition to the abovementioned therapeutic options, cell-mediated therapy based on immune and stem cell has been investigated as a promising option for the treatment of CoV infections. The convalescent plasma of the cured patients contains antiviral antibodies and can be exploited to reduce viral loading and mortality of patients [46, 47]. To date, in cell-based therapy of CoV infections, natural killer (NK) cells and mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have shown bright potentials in the treatment of COVID-19 infection. NK cells can lyse antibody-coated virus-infected cells by mediating antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) against SARS-CoV [48, 49]. MSCs can improve the cytokine storm syndromes, acute respiratory distress syndrome, and lung injury by suppressing the infiltration of immune cells to pulmonary tissues and proinflammatory cytokine secretion which can be a valuable treatment to inhibit the COVID-19-associated lung damage [50, 51]. Also, TCM has been used as a complementary therapy for CoV-infected patients, declining the side effects of conventional therapeutics. TCM herb formulae can be used to inhibit the activity of CoV infections via different mechanisms especially inhibition of the enzymatic activities and cellular entry. Based on Table 1, several TCM formulations are now available in clinical trials [52]. Lately, in order to address the drawbacks of conventional prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of coronaviruses infections, the research community turned to nanotechnology to implement a new efficient nanotechnology-based approach to combat infections with coronaviruses which will be addressed in the next sections.

4. Nanotechnology in Coronavirus Infections

Nanotechnology is referring to design, synthesis, and application of materials with at least nanoscale size (<100 nm) in one dimension. Owing to small size, large surface area, and high loading capacities, as well as specific optical properties of NPs, they have been widely explored in a variety of biological systems to attain the intended therapeutic or diagnostic performance [116120]. Currently, a variety of NPs have been explored as nanopharmaceuticals, or nanosized pharmaceuticals, for prevention and treatment of various human diseases such as viral infections. Most of approved nanoproducts in market have revealed lower toxicities and higher therapeutic efficacy compared to conventional formulations. Nonetheless, nanoformulations currently in clinical trials have demonstrated positive outcomes; thus, they are likely to be approved by the regulators in preceding years [121, 122]. Today, one important application in response to the increasing prevalence of viral infections especially coronavirus infections is the development of improved antiviral products. NPs applied in prevention, detection, and treatment of CoV infections are illustrated in Figure 1. Table 3 summarizes the description, pros and cons, and potential roles of NPs in coronavirus infections. In the next section, the application of NPs in prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of CoVs will be discussed.

4.1. Nanotechnology in the Prevention of Coronavirus Infections

The recent outbreak of CoV infection in the absence of effective conventional treatments highlights the importance of prevention and control of CoV transmission. Advances in nanotechnology have led to the development of nanotechnology-based vaccines, masks, and disinfectants for controlling CoV infections which are presented in the next sections.

4.2. Nanotechnology-Based Vaccines for Coronavirus Infections

Nowadays, vaccination has gained increasing attention owing to its promising results to combat various infections and to reduce the costs as well as deaths worldwide [128]. The recent rapid emergence of CoV infection has shown that vaccination can act as a significant function in managing the social safety and public health. Coronavirus vaccination may either preserve people against infection or have a therapeutic impact. However, development of CoV vaccines has encountered some limitations including inadequate protectivity, the absence of high-throughput animal models, scale-up and GMP production, and safety concerns. There are currently different types of vaccine formulations including attenuated viruses, viral proteins (subunits or virus-like particles), nucleic acids, or recombinant viral vectors that have been used to target diverse CoVs [19, 129, 130]. Nevertheless, they have been significantly correlated with the risk of the weak immune response, reversion to pathogenic virulence, and inadequate immunogenicity and induced partial protection. Hence, while improving safety and efficiency of candidate vaccines, alternative options should be considered in vaccine development to shorten the access time. Nowadays, nanotechnology-based vaccination systems have shown promising potentials in resolving the limitations of conventional vaccine formulations. They have several capabilities such as (i) delivery of different types of vaccines; (ii) vaccine administration through nasal or oral routes to stimulate mucosal immune reactions; (iii) targeted and controlled release of single or multiple antigens to antigen-presenting cells, leading to prolonged half-life and antigen presentation to the immune cells; (iv) boosted immunogenicity of vaccines and adjuvants; (v) decline in the potential antigen toxicity; (vi) protection of the encapsulated antigens under harsh conditions; and (vii) stimulation of the immune response as adjuvants [131, 132]. Such findings and observations have inspired material scientists to imitate viral infection for production of nanotechnology-based vaccination systems. Design of CoV vaccines adopts various strategies; however, most of them target the structural proteins including S or spike, N, envelope (E), and membrane (M) proteins that they might act as the most important inducers of neutralizing antibodies [19]. Following the identification of the SARS-CoV-2 structural proteins and promising results in development of the synthetic virus-like NPs [133, 134], Chen and coworkers recently developed a synthetic virus-like particle (sVLP) based on spontaneous protein corona formation using AuNPs and an avian CoV spike protein for vaccination in IBV-CoV infection, as presented in Figure 2 [135]. Developed sVLP formulation led to efficient lymphatic antigen delivery, stronger antibody titers, increased splenic T cell response, and reduced infection-associated symptoms in an avian model of CoV infection in comparison to vaccination with free proteins. Moreover, in comparison with a commercial whole inactivated virus vaccine, sVLPs offered superior antiviral protection. In addition to AuNPs, polymeric NPs have been recently applied as sVLPs for promoting immune cell engagement and antigen processing against CoV infections. For instance, Tasca and coworkers developed a viral capsid-like hollow poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) NP for entrapment of cyclic diguanylate monophosphate (cdGMP), a canonical stimulator of interferon genes (STING) agonist. The cdGMP upregulates the proinflammatory cytokines to shape the adaptive immunity, as an adjuvant, and recombinant MERS-CoV RBD antigens as Th1 immune responses and cellular immunity promoters against the MERS-CoV infectious. The developed formulation showed significant antigen-specific cellular and humoral responses in immunized mice [136].

In addition to synthetic NPs, MERS-CoV spike protein NPs have been employed against MERS-CoV infection. In this strategy, MERS-CoV S protein NPs are combined with an appropriate adjuvant to promote sufficient immunization against CoV infections. Coleman et al. showed the applicability of MERS-CoV S protein NPs to prompt a robust neutralizing antibody response to MERS-CoV [137]. Following the mentioned research, they developed a formulation using MERS-CoV spike protein NPs and Matrix-M1 adjuvant to protect mice against MERS-CoV infection [138]. Their results indicated that adjuvant combination with MERS-CoV S protein NPs can neutralize antibody response in vaccinated mice as well as providing efficient MERS-CoV replication blocking in the lungs. Furthermore, Jung et al. developed vaccination formulation based on recombinant adenovirus serotype 5 delivering the MERS-CoV S protein gene (Ad5/MERS) and MERS S protein NPs with alum adjuvant to induce cellular and humoral immune responses with heterologous prime-boost vaccination strategy [139]. Results showed not only Ad5/MERS-induced-specific immunoglobulin G but also MERS S protein NP-induced-specific IgG. The results also revealed that just heterologous prime-boost immunization and homologous immunization with S protein NPs can induce MERS-CoV- neutralizing antibodies. Additionally, Ad5/MERS can induce Th1 cell activation, alone or in combination with S protein NPs. However, heterologous prime-boost vaccination Ad5/MERS regimens caused Th1 and Th2 responses, while homologous prime-boost vaccination did not exhibit any Th1 and Th2 responses indicating more usefulness of heterologous prime-boost for long-lasting immune responses against MERS-CoV. NPs could be also employed as adjuvants to prevent CoV infections. NPs have been administrated in combination with antigens as an adjuvant to enhance the immunization of vaccine systems. Sekimukai and colleagues developed two types of vaccine adjuvants based on AuNPs and Toll-like receptor (TLR) agonists to increase the efficacy of intranasally administrated ultraviolet- (UV-) inactivated SARS-CoV vaccine [140]. Surface adsorbed recombinant CoV S protein AuNPs showed antigen-specific IgG response; however, it was unsuccessful to make a protective antibody and eosinophilic infiltration in the lungs in comparison to TLR agonists which effectively reduced the required extent of recombinant S protein for the vaccination and eosinophilic infiltration in the lungs after the SARS-CoV infection. Today, concerning the importance of CoV S protein in CoV vaccine development, Novavax, an American vaccine development company, has developed several recombinant NP-based vaccine candidates to target surface S protein of MERS infection which are in animal models’ testing stage [24]. The surface ligands of COVID-19 have also attracted the attention of NanoViricides company to develop a nanoformulation based on nanoviricide® technology [24]. In nanoviricides, polymeric micelles comprise a single-chain polymer conjugated to specific ligands that help in engulfing or coating the virus, resulting in virus neutralization and destabilization and may be viral genome attacking [141].

Currently, numerous antigens or adjuvants have been loaded into NPs to target antigen-presenting cells (APCs) resulting in efficient antigen recognition and presentation [142, 143]. Raghuwanshi and coworkers encapsulated plasmid DNA-encoding N protein (pVAXN) of SARS-CoV into biotinylated chitosan NPs for nasal immunization [144]. Biotinylated chitosan NPs were surface-functionalized with a recombinant bifunctional fusion protein (bfFp) which contains a single-chain variable fragment (scFv) to target DEC 205 receptors of DCs. The positively charged chitosan NPs can efficiently bind to negative sialic residues in the nasal mucus. The slow release of the formulation as well as the transient opening of the tight junctions can enhance paracellular transport across the nasal mucosa. Moreover, the binding of receptor-specific ligands to chitosan microspheres enables receptor-mediated endocytosis leading to cell-specific delivery vaccine formulations [145, 146]. The polymeric nanoformulation vaccines are resistant to DNAse; thus, they can act as an in vivo efficient vaccination system. Intranasal administration of targeted polymeric nanoformulation in combination with anti-CD40 DC maturation stimuli can enhance the mucosal IgA and systemic content of IgG against N protein of SARS-CoV; however, no mucosal and systemic immune responses were observed for bare pDNA. Furthermore, results indicated higher systemic IgG responses for intramuscular injection of bare pVAXN or NP-loaded pVAXN as compared with the intranasal administration. Such a difference could be due to the low dosage of bare or nanoencapsulated DNA. In a study, Sun et al. showed that intramuscular administration of chitosan-encapsulated N protein of bovine CoV (BCV N) NPs can significantly enhance IgA and IgG levels as compared to Montanide ISA 206, an oil adjuvant, effectiveness of chitosan NPs to be used as an adjuvant for BCV N protein [147]. Altogether, nanotechnology-based vaccine formulations are promising immune cell activators and antigen carriers for vaccination, but further studies are still required.

4.3. Nanotechnology in Prevention of Coronavirus Infections

As previously mentioned in Section 3, blocking transmission routes especially the mouth and nose is an important strategy to combat CoVs. Hence, efficient personal protection devices against CoV nanoscale aerosols have attracted increasing attention. However, N95 and N98 masks protect people against aerosols with 300 nm, smaller aerosols, and airborne viruses might be transmitted to the respiratory system, resulting in infection. Concerning the nanoscale size of CoVs, many research groups are focused on the production of nanofilter masks to prevent the transmission of CoV aerosols smaller than 300 nm. Recently, Leung and Sun have designed a nanofiber filter based on a single or multiple layers of electrostatically charged polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) nanofibers (with size ranges of 84, 191, 349, and 525 nm) deposited on a mat substrate to capture airborne COVID-19 and nanoaerosols with less than 300 nm [148]. Results indicated that smaller nanofibers (84 nm) can offer higher mechanical capturing of neutral sodium chloride aerosols used as a virus model, which can be assigned to their large specific surface. In comparison to single-layer filters based on small nanofibers, small and large multilayer nanofiber filters were capable of capturing 90% of simulated 100 nm in size airborne COVID-19 which might be more hopeful for viruses with negative charges. In another research, they have developed a charged PVDF multilayer nanofiber filter to filter the simulated airborne COVID-19 using ambient nanoaerosols. Their results showed 6-layer charged nanofiber filter could be used to filter the nanoaerosols sizes of 50, 100, and 300 nm ambient aerosols with 88%, 88%, and 96% capture efficiency while the filtering efficiencies of 92%, 94%, and 98% could be achieved for the sodium chloride aerosols with the same size order [149]. Recently, a Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology developed a washable and ethanol-sterilizable nanofiber-based filter that can be easily fitted inside a conventional mask to filter 94% of contaminants [150].

4.4. Nanotechnology-Based Surface Disinfectant in Coronavirus Infections

As another exposure-reducing strategy toward CoVs and concerning the importance of the contaminated surfaces in the spread of the CoVs, specific attention has also paid to decontamination of surfaces using 70–85% ethanol, NaClO, and iodine-based disinfectants [151]. On the other hand, findings have approved the antiviral activity of NPs, resulting in their usage as surface disinfectants with cell membrane entrance virus replication inhibition as well as surface attachment interfere of the virus into cells [152]. Therefore, the Nanotech Surface Company has recently developed a self-sterilizing formulation based on titanium dioxide and silver ions to disinfect buildings in Milan [153]. Taken together, nanotechnology-based filters (face masks) and disinfectants are promising products for personal and public protections against CoVs which require further research.

4.5. Nanotechnology in the Diagnosis of Coronavirus Infections

Rapid and precise detection technique can reduce the spread and morbidity of CoV infections. There are numerous techniques being employed for the detection of CoV infections; however, most of them suffer from some limitations including low sensitivity, time-consuming procedures, high costs, and late detection [154]. The current standard technique for CoV detection, RT-PCR, is a highly time-consuming technique requiring expert users, and complex devices, highlighting the need for sensitive and early detection of CoV infection. Novel detection assays based on nanotechnology have gained increasing attention. The unique properties of NPs such as their high surface area, easy functionalization, and special optical properties have led to their application as rapid, sensitive, and cost-effective diagnostic systems with less sample volume and laboratory equipment [155, 156]. During the last decades, a great deal of effort has been dedicated to the use of NPs in the design of various nanobiosensors for the detection of infectious diseases [156]. In this section, different applications of NPs in design of colorimetric, optical, and electrochemical sensors for detection of CoV infections are presented.

4.6. Nanotechnology in Colorimetric Detection of Coronavirus Infections

Colorimetric biosensors are sensitive, selective, and low-cost detection tools capable of detecting analytes based on color changes that can be easily recognized by naked eyes or simple portable optical detectors [157159]. Special physicochemical properties of NPs have led to emergence of new colorimetric diagnostic systems [160]. Among various NPs, AuNPs have gained increasing attention in the development of biosensors owning to their fascinating optical properties which are related to the strong surface plasmon resonance (SPR) absorption. SPR is generated by the incidence of light on a metal surface, causing collective coherent oscillation of conduction electrons. If frequency of the light source matches with that of the surface plasmon, amplitude of the electron oscillation increases which is known as SPR or localized SPR (LSPR) in NPs, resulting in strong absorption of the incident light which can be measured using a UV-Vis spectrometer [161]. The SPR can be affected by shape, size, and the dielectric constant of metal and the distance among the NPs [162]. Dispersed AuNPs, as one of the plasmonic NPs, have shown a specific color or LSPR band which may change into another color or LSPR band upon the addition of external materials such as biomolecules or ions [163, 164]. Recently, Kim and coworkers designed a colorimetric test based on AuNPs and thiol-modified probes for targeting partial genomic regions of MERS-CoV [165]. As shown in Figure 3, they designed thiol-modified probes linked to citrate-coated AuNPs via strong Au–S interactions to target the upstream of the E protein gene (upE) and open reading frames (ORF) 1a on MERS-CoV. A combination of thiol-modified probes and AuNPs at the presence of MgCl2 led to the aggregation of AuNPs with a reduction in intensity and an increase in bandwidth of LSPR band as well as the emergence of new bands at a longer wavelength. However, the presence of target DNA led to the formation of long assemblies of dsDNA on the surface of AuNPs and shielded the disulfide bands leading to inhibition of the AuNP aggregation by MgCl2 which limited the color change for diagnosis of MERS-CoV.

AuNP can be also used in combination with other diagnostic systems such as fiber-optic biosensors to achieve sensitive virus detection. For example, Huang et al. developed a localized surface plasmon-coupled fluorescence (LSPCF) fiber-optic biosensor utilizing AuNPs for the identification of SARS-CoV N protein. Compared to the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) toward the same monoclonal antibodies, the LSPCF fiber-optic biosensor exhibited a 104 time limit detection improvement [166].

4.7. Nanotechnology in Electrochemical Sensing of Coronavirus Infections

Another analytical methodology that has explored for detection of viral infections is the electrochemical sensing [167, 168]. Conventional electrochemical sensors include an electrolyte, a diffusion barrier, a sensing electrode (as transduction element), and a counter-reference electrode, resulting electrical signal from the interaction of target analyte and recognition layer of sensing electrode. Fascinating properties of NPs (especially metallic and semiconductor NPs) including high surface area, conductivity, and catalytic properties have led to their use in (i) surface immobilization of biomolecules, (ii) enrichment of electron transfer, (iii) effective catalysis, and (iv) labeling biomolecules [169]. The electrochemical immunosensors are comprised of an electrode surface immobilization with recognition component (i.e., antibody or antigen) and gained promising attention as reliable and efficient sensing platform for detection of viral infections [170, 171]. Layqah and Eissa developed a competitive electrochemical immunosensor for sensitive, cost-effective, and user-friendly sensing for the multiplexed detection of different CoVs, as depicted in Figure 4. AuNPs were electrodeposited on a carbon electrode (DEP) (AuNP/DEP) to increase the electron transfer efficiency and provide a higher surface area to improve the biosensor response signal due to presence of more immobilized biomolecules [154]. AuNP/DEP was modified with different antigens such as MERS-CoV, HCoV (Oc43 N), and bovine serum albumin (BSA) as a control electrode. The addition of constant concentration of antibody to the sample containing free virus and immobilized MERS-CoV protein, HCoV, and BSA changed the voltammetric response which can be measured via square wave voltammetry (SWV). Results indicated a linear correlation between the sensor responses and the concentrations as well as lower detection limits for artificial spiked nasal samples of MERS-CoV and HCoV.

In addition to AuNPs, QDs have been employed for the development of biosensors. Recently, Roh developed a biochip through modification by SARS-CoV N protein and QD-conjugated RNA oligonucleotide and tested the inhibitor screening of SARS-CoV N protein ability of fabricated biochip using several polyphenolic compounds (Figure 5). Among different polyphenolic compounds, gallate and (-)-gallocatechin gallate with anti-HIV properties showed higher and equal half-maximal inhibitory concentration (IC50) values on a QDs-RNA oligonucleotide biochip in comparison with other polyphenolic compounds. The results revealed that biochips not only led to the specific detection of the SARS-CoV N protein but also could be used for inhibitor screening of SARS-CoV N protein [172]. Moreover, Zhu and coworkers coupled NP-based biosensors (NBS) with reverse transcription loop-mediated isothermal amplification (RT-LAMP) for the diagnosis of COVID-19 which resulted in the selective and sensitive detection of SARS-CoV-2 [6]. Taken together, electrochemical sensing might be promising technique for the rapid detection of CoV infections. For more detailed information, interested reader is referred to excellent review on this topic by Kaushik and coworkers [173].

4.8. Nanotechnology in RT-PCR-Based Detection of Coronavirus Infections

As mentioned earlier, RT-PCR is the main conventical diagnostic method for CoV infections. This method requires the extraction of high-purity nucleic acids to produce strong signals and low false negative results [174, 175]. Regarding that present methods for the extraction of nucleic acids using filtration or centrifugation are very time-consuming and labor-intensive, the application magnetic NPs in sample preparation have fascinated more attention. Magnetic NPs can be easily separated from the media using an external magnetic field during the sample preparation, also called preenrichment [176]. In recent years, magnetic NPs have gained promising attention as solid-phase adsorbents of various biomacromolecules; this method is superior over conventional procedures due to shorter processing times, decreased chemical consumption, and simpler procedure via automation [177]. For this purpose, Zhao and coworkers developed poly(amino ester) with carboxyl group- (PC-) coated magnetic NPs (pcMNPs) for the extraction of SARS-CoV-2 RNA, resulting in the sensitive detection of COVID-19 via RT-PCR [178]. In comparison to column-based nucleic acid extraction methods, pcMNPs showed a rapid simple extraction with high purity and productivity with the assistance of an external magnet, resulting in time-consuming RNA extraction for the diagnosis of COVID-19. Taken together, as presented in Table 3, NPs might be promising materials for the detection and extraction of CoV infections. Further experiments are still necessary to assess their safety and efficacy.

4.9. Nanotechnology in the Treatment of Coronavirus Infections

The absence of specific anti-CoV drugs and also the continuous advent of new CoV infections rise the demand for specific antiviral therapies. As mentioned before, current COVID-19 therapies are deduced from MERS-CoV, SARS-CoV, and H1N1 influenza which are a combination of different antiviral agents including protease inhibitors, nucleoside analogs, and corticosteroids. Nowadays, with the advancement of nanotechnology, a growing focus has been devoted to nanoscale antiviral materials as efficient modulating process platforms for viral infections [179]. Nanoscale antiviral materials can be used for (i) targeted delivery of pharmacological agents to the sites of CoV infections, (ii) prolonged drug release for efficient treatment, (iii) decreasing the drug toxicity and associated side effects, (iv) improving the drug efficacy and potency, (v) delivery of gene and/or immune-based therapies, and (vi) targeting the virus entrance mechanism. Numerous nanoscale antiviral materials have been designed to interfere with the virus and cell receptor interactions. In fact, the high surface-to-volume ratio of NPs led to their efficient attachment to the healthy or noncontaminated cells which result in blocking virus entrance into cells [180].

Recently, the ability of carbon quantum dots (CQDs) to interfere with the HIV-1 and herpes simplex virus type 1 cell entrance has led to the use of boronic acid-functionalized CQDs for the treatment of HCoV-229E infection [181183]. Łoczechin et al. synthesized seven CQD derivatives which had dose-dependent anti-HCoV-229E activity [184]. Among the CQDs, just boronic acid-functionalized CQDs exhibited anti-HCoV-229E activity; but the low content boronic acid derivatives of CQDs showed lower EC50 in comparison to the higher content of boronic acid derivatives. Results also revealed that the boronic acid derivatives of CQDs not only caused an interaction with cell entry factors but also affect the genomic replication of the HCoV-229E virus. Consequently, boronic acid-functionalized CQDs might be regarded as a therapeutic agent for COVID-19. Moreover, in the functionalization of nanomaterials to improve their antiviral activities, their shape plays an effective role in their antiviral activity. However, most of the reported antiviral nanomaterials are spherical; nonspherical nanomaterials may display higher antiviral effects compared to their spherical peers [185]. Recently, Zhou et al. reported that mercaptoethane sulfonate-functionalized bovine serum albumin- (BSA-) coated tellurium star-shaped NPs (Te/BSA NPs) are able to suppress the internalization process of porcine epidemic diarrhea virus (PEDV), a model of CoV, more than the spherical Te/BSA NPs, which might be due to its more interactions with viruses. Moreover, free mercaptoethane sulfonate did not show any significant antiviral effect on PRRSV probably because of its free rotation which may lead to its weak binding affinity to viral proteins. The star-shaped Te/BSA NPs showed higher distribution in the cytoplasm leading to a decline in reactive oxygen species (ROS) content of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus- (PRRSV-) infected MARC-145 cells, hence resulting in cell apoptosis or even necrosis [186]. Apart from interfering with protein S-receptor interaction, NPs have been applied to target vacuolar ATPase (V-ATPase) activity, which pumps protons into endosomal compartments. Recently, Hu and coworkers prepared poly(ethylene glycol)-block-poly(lactide-co-glycolide) (PEG-PLGA) NPs to target feline CoV (FCoV) infection [187]. They encapsulated diphyllin, a natural V-ATPase inhibitor into PEG-PLGA NPs to reduce its off-target effect and increase its antiviral activity. PEG-PLGA NPs showed dose-dependent endosomal acidification inhibition activity in (felis catus whole fetus-4) cell line as well as in vitro prominent antiviral effect against the feline infectious peritonitis virus (FIPV), a biotype of FCoV.

Recently, the combination of nanotechnology and human natural stem cell-based therapies has led to emergence of new strategies in treatment of various deceases. For example, “LIFNano” (leukemia inhibitory factor nanoformulation), a synthetic stem cell product with the current indication in multiple sclerosis (MS) and rheumatoid arthritis, has attracted much interest in the management of COVID-19 pneumonia [188, 189]. The surface ligands of COVID-19 have also attracted the attention of NanoViricides company to develop a nanoformulation based on nanoviricide® technology [24]. Nanoviricide®, an antiviral polymeric nanomicelle-based formulation for influenza, HIV, herpes, etc., comprises a single-chain polymer conjugated to specific ligands that help in engulfing or coating the virus, resulting in virus neutralization and destabilization and may be viral genome attacking [141]. Taken together, nanotechnology-based antiviral materials might be promising options for the treatment of CoV infections. Further experiments are, however, necessary to assess their safety and efficacy.

5. Conclusion

Combating CoV infections is an enormous challenge for healthcare systems, primarily due to its high transmittance rate, and the virus potential to survive through multiple mutations. Up to now, few drugs have been approved for CoV infections (especially COVID-19); however, the development and design of old and new drugs are still urgently necessary for humans. Currently, there are some authorized vaccines for COVID-19 protection, but it is highly important to prevent its spread by various techniques, such as the isolation of infected patients, the use of personal protective devices and disinfectants, and rapid and early detection systems. As new systems, the benefits of nanotechnology result in the design and development of different nanoscale systems for the prevention, treatment, and diagnosis of CoV infections. Nanotechnology-based formulations can offer controlled and sustained release of antigens and therapeutic agents, as well as interfering with the entry of the virus into cells to enhance the prevention and treatment measures toward CoV infections. Moreover, nanotechnology can help in the development of rapid, cost-effective, and high-sensitive diagnostics systems for CoV infections. However, the majority of studies in the field of CoV nanotechnology continues in the preliminary drug development phases, and problems remain until these systems can progress into clinical use. The efficacy, stability, and safety of nanoscale-based prevention and therapeutic and diagnosis systems must be evaluated by relevant clinical endpoints. Ongoing studies to address these issues must continue. Ultimately, nanotechnology provides several interesting systems to promote the fields of CoV prevention, treatment, and diagnosis.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

Acknowledgments

This work was financially supported by the Shiraz University of Medical Sciences.