The aim of this study was to investigate a novel and convenient method of chemical treatment to modify the hydrophilicity of titanium surfaces. Sand-blasted and acid-etched (SLA) titanium surfaces and machined titanium surfaces were treated with sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3) solution. The wetting behavior of both kinds of surfaces was measured by water contact angle (WCA) test. The surface microstructure was assessed with scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and three-dimensional (3D) optical microscopy. The elemental compositions of the surfaces were analyzed by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The protein adsorption analysis was performed with fibronectin. Results showed that, after 1 M NaHCO3 treatment, the hydrophilicity of both SLA and machined surfaces was enhanced. No significant microstructural change presented on titanium surfaces after NaHCO3 treatment. The deprotonation and ion exchange activities might cause the enhanced hydrophilicity of titanium surfaces. The increased protein adsorption of NaHCO3-treated SLA surfaces might indicate their improved tissue-integration in clinical use.

1. Introduction

Titanium implant is widely used in dentistry because of its extraordinary biocompatibility and mechanical properties [1]. The tissue-integration of titanium surface plays a key role in the long-term clinical success. Different surface treatments that favor the bioactivity and bioconductivity of titanium implants have been investigated [2].

The interactions between titanium surface and host cells can be influenced by the surface characteristics of implants including topography, chemical properties, surface charge, and hydrophilicity [3]. The modification of Ti surfaces’ topography is claimed to be influential to protein adsorption, osteoblast proliferation and differentiation, and tissue-integration [4].

Sand-blasted and acid-etched (SLA) Ti surface implants are widely used in clinical dental practice. This kind of surface is reported to have micro- and nanometer scale topography created by blasting and acid-etching processes. It was suggested that the topography of biomaterial surface in micro- or nanometer scale can promote higher cell-adhesion strengths [5].

Additionally, surface charge, surface energy, hydrophilicity, and other physicochemical properties of implant surfaces can also influence tissue-integration. In the last decade, interest in the hydrophilicity property of titanium surface has increased in both in vitro [6, 7] and in vivo [7, 8] studies. Most of these studies stated that hydrophilicity enhanced cell adhesion, proliferation and differentiation, and bone mineralization at an early stage [9, 10].

Hence, various techniques were attempted to increase the hydrophilicity of implant surfaces [1114]. Nonetheless, these attempts of different techniques are argued to be either unpractical with high-standard technical requirements and rather long processing time or requiring severe chemical conditions, which, in clinical implantology, might probably impede the proposed application of the treated specimens.

Recently, a chemical treatment with NaOH has been reported to significantly improve the hydrophilicity of titanium surfaces [15, 16]. Performed by soaking the Ti discs or implants in 0.05 M NaOH for 30 s at room temperature, this treatment was reported to support fast and homogenous protein adsorption and consecutive osseointegration [15, 17]. Furthermore, it was also stated that enhanced surface energy by NaOH-induced hydrophilicity is responsible for the promotion of blood components adhesion [15] and cell adhesion to titanium surfaces [18]. NaOH-treated Ti implants were demonstrated with stronger osseointegrative potential in vivo as well [19]. Stadlinger et al. tested NaOH-treated and untreated implants in the mandible of an in vivo minipig model. By comparing the removal torque and interfacial stiffness, surfaces of NaOH-treated implants exhibited a tendency to promote early peri-implant bone formation [20].

Sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO3) solution is widely used as mouth-rinse in clinic for oral hygiene maintenance [21]. The aim of this study was to develop a mild alkali treatment method for preparing enhanced hydrophilic Ti implant surfaces. The experiment was designed for SLA and machined Ti implant surfaces to be treated with 1 M NaHCO3 solution. In this study, detailed physicochemical characterization of the NaHCO3-treated Ti surfaces is presented as key findings. The influences of surface roughness and surface chemistry on the hydrophilicity transformations of the specimens were also evaluated. This evaluation was performed by measuring changes in the physicochemical properties of the Ti specimens with respect to chemical surface treatment and surface roughness. Fibronectin adsorption ability on NaHCO3-treated SLA Ti surfaces was also investigated by comparing with untreated SLA Ti surfaces.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Specimen Preparation

Two types of Ti discs were employed as experiment specimens,which were machined and SLA Ti discs (Wego Jericom Biomaterials Co., Weihai, China). Both kinds of the discs have a diameter of 15 mm and a thickness of 1 mm. Machined Ti discs were made of commercially pure titanium that conformed with ISO 5832-2 grade 4 by milling process. As stated in the previous study [22], SLA discs were produced by sand-blasting machined Ti discs with Al2O3 particles (particle size 250–500 μm) and then acid-etching the specimens in a boiling mixture of hydrochloric and sulphuric acid. Both discs were treated in nitric acid, deionised water, and air in sequence for them to be cleaned, rinsed, and dried correspondingly. At last, discs were stored in aluminum foil.

2.2. NaHCO3 Solution Treatment

NaHCO3 solution treatment was performed at room temperature. The SLA and machined Ti discs were assigned into three groups according to the difference in their chemical states, which were untreated (i.e., “untreated” group), treated with 1 M NaHCO3 solution (i.e., “NaHCO3-treated” group), and treated with 1 M NaHCO3 solution and rinsed with Milli-Q water (Milli-Q Advantage, Millipore, France) for three times (i.e., “rinsed” group). Specimens in the untreated group maintain their original properties for further comparison. All specimens were then blow-dried in a nitrogen stream shortly before being measured.

2.3. Surface Hydrophilicity Assessment

The hydrophilicity of SLA and machined Ti discs in the untreated, NaHCO3-treated and rinsed group was examined both quantitatively and qualitatively by water contact angle (WCA) test, which is formed by a 10 μL drop of distilled water on the Ti surfaces. The measurement was performed by a contact angle system (OCA20, Dataphysics, Germany). All of the WCA data were obtained by ellipse methods. In this measurement process, specimens from both NaHCO3-treated and rinsed group were further divided into 4 subgroups, each being soaked in NaHCO3 solution for 30 s, 1 min, 3 min, or 5 min, respectively. The average WCAs of the 4 samples in each subgroup were evaluated and then compared with each other and the ones in the untreated group. The subgroups were set up in order to observe the effects of soaking time on wetting behavior.

2.4. Surface Microstructure Characterization

In order to observe the microstructure of SLA and machined discs and to analyze what influences NaHCO3 treatment had on materials’ topography change, a scanning electron microscope (SEM) (S-3000N, Hitachi, Japan) and a three-dimensional (3D) optical microscope (Contour GT, Bruker, US) were utilized to analyze the specimens before and after a 3 min NaHCO3 treatment. A period of 3 minutes can be a suitable treatment time according to the results of the hydrophilicity assessment experiment (see Section 3.1 for details).

The SEM scanned specimens coated with gold at 15.0 kV and a magnification of 2000x. Surface roughness data and 3D images of the specimens were acquired by the 3D optical microscopy. Roughness data were then analyzed with Vision64 software. Four specimens from each group were evaluated by observing four random spots on each of them. The average values of their roughness average (), maximum peak height (), root mean square roughness (), and maximum height of the profile () were hence calculated.

2.5. Surfaces’ Elemental Composition

An X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) (ESCALAB 250 Xi, Thermo Scientific, US) that uses monochromatic radiation was employed to analyze surface elemental composition of the SLA specimens in three groups. Survey (wide-scan) spectra were recorded with a pass energy level of 100 eV and a resolution of 1.000 eV, while high-resolution (narrow-scan) spectra were obtained with a pass energy level of 30 eV and a resolution of 0.050 eV for C1 and O1. In each specimen group, three discs were tested. According to the methods suggested by McCafferty and Wightman, peak attribution and selection of full width at half maximum values were then executed to fit the high-resolution spectra [23]. All binding energies were checked in reference to the carbon C-H photopeak at 285.0 eV. High-resolution spectra for C1 and O1 were further analyzed using XPSPEAK 4.1 software.

2.6. Protein Adsorption

SLA specimens in both untreated and NaHCO3-treated groups participated in this section. The NaHCO3-treated specimens were immersed in the solution for 3 min. The treated specimens were carefully cleaned by a lint-free cleaning wipe to remove any residual solution and then blow-dried in a nitrogen stream.

1 μM fibronectin (HiLyte Fluor 488 labeled) solution was prepared in 20 mM NaCl-buffer according to the instructions from HiLyte and was then directly applied in the experiments. Protein adsorption tests were executed with sandwich assay. 10 μL of the protein solution was incubated between an SLA disk and a round-shaped microscopy glass cover slip with a diameter of 12 mm for 5 min. The process was carried out in a dark environment with saturated humidity at room temperature. Afterwards, the specimens were rinsed with 20 mM NaCl-buffer for 3 times (5 min each time) to remove loosely bound fibronectin on the SLA surfaces. Finally, specimens were analyzed using a confocal microscopy (LSM710, Zeiss, Germany) with an excitation wavelength of 488 nm and a cut of filter of 505–550 nm for detection. The adsorption of protein on the specimens was evaluated by measuring relative fluorescence intensity with the help from ImageJ (NIH, Bethesda, MD, USA) software.

2.7. Statistical Analysis

All data presented in this study are expressed as “mean ± standard deviation (SD).” Data were subjected to an independent samples -test or one-way ANOVA using SPSS 22.0 software for Mac. For analysis in this paper, significant differences were ones with a .

3. Results

3.1. Surface Hydrophilicity Assessment

The effects of surface energy changes were analyzed by measuring the WCAs on SLA and machined Ti surfaces. The rinsed group was arranged to clarify if the increased hydrophilicity of NaHCO3-treated specimens was just temporary because of the adhesion of Na+ and negative ions (, , , etc.) on the specimen surfaces.

Figure 1 shows the WCAs of SLA surfaces under three states: untreated, NaHCO3-treated for 3 min, and rinsed. According to Figure 1, the WCA of untreated SLA disc was obtuse. After NaHCO3 treatment, WCA was nearly 0. This angle was maintained after the disc being rinsed. Table 1 and Figure 2 show the WCAs of the SLA and machined specimens from three test groups with different chemical states. As evidenced by Table 1, the WCAs of untreated Ti specimens increased from 86° on the smooth machined surfaces to 130° on the SLA specimens. Therefore, untreated SLA specimens could be classified as hydrophobic. Also, it could be seen that the WCAs of both SLA and machined specimens decreased with increasing treatment time. However, while the machined surfaces had only displayed a relatively small decrement, data of SLA surfaces showed rapid decline, for a treatment time more than 1 min, and the WCAs of the NaHCO3-treated SLA specimens were recorded to be extremely close to zero. This change in hydrophilicity upon NaHCO3 treatment shifted the SLA specimens from hydrophobic to superhydrophilic. Also, notice that by comparing the NaHCO3-treated and rinsed groups, it could be argued that the superhydrophilicity of NaHCO3-treated SLA specimens could be fully preserved after rinsing.

After 3 minutes of NaHCO3 treatment and rinsing, the SLA and machined specimens were exposed in the air for 120 min, within which WCAs were measured again at different time points. Table 2 and Figure 3 show that the value of WCAs increased with longer exposure time. From the shown data, it can be concluded that the SLA specimens can remain superhydrophilic for at least 10 min.

3.2. Surface Microstructure Characterization

The SEM micrograph in Figure 4(a) illustrates the complex microstructure of an untreated SLA surface. Sand-blasting and acid-etching produced cavities and micropits were observed. Moreover, Figure 4(c) displays the profile of an untreated machined surface that exhibits less roughness. By comparing the SEM results of the untreated surfaces (Figures 4(a) and 4(c)) and the NaHCO3-treated surfaces (Figures 4(b) and 4(d)), it can be seen that both the SLA and machined Ti surfaces experienced no significant morphological differences before and after the NaHCO3 treatment.

The 3D images in Figure 5 and the roughness data in Table 3 were both output from the 3D optical microscopy. 3D images display no apparent discrepancy between the untreated and NaHCO3-treated surfaces of both SLA and machined specimens. Similarly, the roughness measurements of the two surfaces before and after 3 min NaHCO3 treatment in Table 3 demonstrate a more quantifiable version of this statement. A comparison can be made by observing Table 3. Mean was 0.15 μm for the untreated machined surfaces and 0.14 μm for the NaHCO3-treated ones, while for the SLA surfaces mean was 2.04 μm before the treatment and 2.09 μm after it. values for both surfaces are larger than 0.05. Therefore, a conclusion can be reached that being treated with NaHCO3 solution does not produce significant difference in the roughness of both machined and SLA specimens.

3.3. Surface Elemental Composition Analysis

Utilizing the XPS software, initially, the survey spectra were analyzed. Figures 6(a), 6(b), and 6(c) show the survey spectra of untreated, NaHCO3-treated, and rinsed SLA Ti surfaces, respectively. According to Figure 6(a), the survey spectra of the untreated SLA specimens consist of titanium (Ti), oxygen (O), and carbon (C) as main elements. While it is apparent in Figure 6(b) that, after NaHCO3 treatment, sodium (Na) signal was detected as another main element, the other three main elements, O, C and Ti, all had a change in their substance amount rate (counts/s). However, Figure 6(c) does not reflect any significant differences in elemental composition between data of the untreated and rinsed groups. Based on the survey spectra, detailed elemental compositions of the surfaces are derived and recorded in Tables 4, 5, and 6.

Table 4 represents the relative elemental compositions of three SLA surfaces groups. It was shown that the untreated group displayed an O/C ratio of 1.42 and a relative C content of 33.2%. After the NaHCO3 treatment, the proportion of C content had decreased to 25.2% and the O/C ratio had increased to 2.04 as the proportion of O content had an increase of 4%. Data from the rinsed group showed no statistical difference compared to the ones from the untreated group.

C1s signals were considered to be contributed by aliphatic (C-C), ether and alcohol bound (CO), and carboxylate and carbonate bound (CO2  and  CO3) C. After these contributors were allocated, their contribution to the total C substance amount was derived and presented in Table 5. On the untreated SLA specimens, 75.4% of total C content was contributed by aliphatic, 16.4% by CO bound, and 9.1% by CO2 or CO3 bound C. In contrast, these data had, respectively, become 42.5% by aliphatic, 9.5% by CO bound, and 48.0% by CO2 and CO3 bound C after the NaHCO3 treatment, demonstrating decrements in aliphatic, ether, and alcohol bound C but increments in CO2 and CO3 bound C. Data from the rinsed group and the untreated group again showed similarity.

On the other hand, O1s signals were provided by Ti bound (TiO), oxygen bound to multiple carbon atoms (C-O-C), bound OH and ions (OH), and also oxygen atoms multiple-bound to carbon and (). Notice that contributions from and H2O were unable to be measured individually. Table 6 shows that 69.7%   bound, 9.3% CO bound, 18.0% OH bound, and 2.9%   bound O were detected on the untreated SLA specimens while after the NaHCO3 treatment, 20.1%   bound, 17.0% CO bound, 45.2% OH bound, and 17.7%   bound O were recorded. In a word, the contribution from bound O was decreasing and, meanwhile, increments were discovered in the contribution of CO bound, OH bound, and COx bound O.

3.4. Protein Adsorption

The differences of protein adsorption between untreated and NaHCO3-treated SLA Ti discs are showed in Figures 7 and 8. Figure 7 shows the fluorescence micrograph of the untreated and NaHCO3-treated SLA Ti discs after incubation in a 1 μM fibronectin for 5 min and subsequent washing steps. More protein adsorption was found in NaHCO3-treated SLA Ti disc compared to untreated group. Moreover, the protein adsorbed on NaHCO3-treated SLA disc was well-distributed. Fluorescence intensity can represent the relative amount of proteins adsorbed on Ti discs. From Figure 8, the fluorescence intensity of NaHCO3-treated SLA Ti discs was stronger than that of untreated group (mean fluorescence intensity of 0.122 compared with 0.065, resp.; ).

4. Discussion

4.1. Influence of Superhydrophilicity on Osseointegration

Titanium surfaces with WCA above 90° are considered as hydrophobic. On the contrary, WCAs lower than 90° categorize surfaces as hydrophilic, while WCAs too small to be almost neglected describe surfaces as having a superhydrophilic attribute [3]. As stated above, after 3 min of NaHCO3 treatment, the WCAs of SLA discs were nearly 0° in this study, which subsequently transformed the material surface into superhydrophilic state.

Dental implants can be benefited by enhanced hydrophilic characteristic of surfaces due to better osseointegration performance. Ti implants with superhydrophilic surfaces were examined to have superb osseointegrative potential and raised much attention recently [24]. Early phases of osseointegration require osteogenic cells to primarily adhere to the implant surfaces and to further proliferate and differentiate into mature osteoblasts [25]. Hydrophilic surfaces support this process by promoting titanium to interact with cells, biological fluids, and tissues [8, 26]. For instance, cluster formation of osteoblasts as well as the expression of osteogenic genes can be enhanced by hydrophilic surfaces [17, 25, 27]. Superhydrophilic implants can optimize the osseointegration even more as they have proved useful to magnifying the area of bone-to-implant contact and strengthen mechanical fixation in the early healing processes of at least the first 4 weeks after implantation [8]. In this study, the NaHCO3-treated SLA discs had developed superhydrophilicity and been able to maintain it for 10 min. This characteristic indicates that, to apply NaHCO3 treatment to the implants in clinic, there should be adequate time for clinicians to insert implants.

4.2. Regime Behind the Development of Superhydrophilicity

Wennerberg and Albrektsson stated that surfaces with smooth (μm) and minimal roughness ( 0.5–1 μm) showed less strong bone responses than surfaces with higher roughness. Meanwhile, surfaces with moderate roughness ( 1-2 μm) showed stronger bone responses than surfaces with high roughness ( > 2 μm) in some studies [28]. In the presented experiment, values were calculated for both SLA and machined surfaces to attempt to discover potential influences of surface topography on hydrophilicity. The SLA surfaces showed a mean value of about 2 μm, which should be considered to be moderately rough.

It was claimed that microrough Ti surfaces induce more advanced initial hydrophobicity compared with Ti surfaces without microroughness [29]. The same results were discovered in this study. The mean WCAs of untreated SLA and machined specimens were 130° and 86°. On the other hand, on microrough titanium implant surfaces, which were not treated with any alkali, high WCAs are most likely to be caused by air entrapped in the micropores underneath the water droplets, according to the Cassie-Baxter regime [3]. However, for alkali treated microrough Ti specimens, the wetting behaviors were assumed by Tugulu et al. to be caused by a film regime [16]. The cavities of the microrough Ti specimens are supposed to be filled with wetting liquid due to capillary forces. Thus, this film regime is believed to be able to explain the low WCAs on NaHCO3-treated and rinsed SLA specimens.

Moreover, without any specific storage conditions, a thin passivation layer of is formed on untreated native Ti surfaces. However, this layer is observed to be rapidly contaminated by the hydrocarbons adsorption from the environment, which result in the hydrophobicity of Ti specimens and the repelling behaviors to water or biological fluids from tissues. The adsorption of hydrocarbons is considered to be able to change the osseointegrative potential of Ti implants [8, 11, 26]. Attempting to prevent this contamination, Rupp et al. have discovered that storing freshly prepared SLA Ti specimens in sodium chloride solution could significantly reduce the carbon contents on these superhydrophilic specimens to as low as 15%, while 35% of carbon was recorded on the hydrophobic SLA specimens which was stored normally [11]. The findings from these reports agree with the XPS results shown in this study. The reduction of carbon contents on NaHCO3-treated SLA surfaces may be regarded as a possible cause to explain the obtained hydrophilicity of NaHCO3-treated SLA Ti surfaces. However, this regime can yet explain the increased hydrophilicity of the rinsed group specimens whose carbon contents were at a rather high level with no difference with the untreated group.

According to high-resolution O1s signal of the NaHCO3-treated Ti specimens, bound OH and ions were significantly increased after the treating process. It can be reasonably assumed that the existence of NaHCO3 was the source of the ions in the solution. Researchers had claimed the relationship between superhydrophilicity and the amount of these negative charged ions. For instance, superhydrophilicity of NaOH-treated SLA surfaces was indicated to be led by deprotonation and ion exchange of hydroxyl-groups on the surfaces [16]. Moreover, many studies demonstrated that the improvement of surface hydrophilicity was caused by forming of new oxygen-containing groups on the surface, such as -OH and -OOH, for these groups are hydrophilic [30]. Therefore, by concluding from comparing this study with other related literatures while taking the mild conditions of NaHCO3 treatment protocol into account, one might assume that the formation of bound OH and ions on Ti surfaces is one of the major chemical transformations for the presented NaHCO3 treatment of Ti specimens. Also, it should be noticed that the results of SEM and roughness measurement in this study showed that there was no physical change in microstructure of the Ti specimens after NaHCO3 treatment.

4.3. Protein Adsorption

Fibronectin was tested in this study. Generally, fibronectin exists as a protein dimer and it can be discovered in 2 fundamental forms: soluble (component of blood plasma and other fluids) and insoluble (component of the extracellular matrix of various tissues) [31]. As a major adhesion protein of the extracellular matrix, it binds to membrane-spanning receptors (i.e., integrin) and to extracellular components [32]. Among many extracellular matrix proteins, fibronectin is an important protein that can contribute some insight into osteoblast cell differentiation, cell-cell interactions, and cell-matrix interactions [33]. Therefore, this protein was chosen to be involved in this study.

An osteoblast adhesion process consists of protein adsorption, cell interaction with the adsorbed proteins, cell attachment, and spreading on implant surfaces. This process plays an essential part of osseointegration [34].

Observing from Figure 8, the fluorescence intensity of NaHCO3-treated specimens was significantly higher than untreated specimens, indicating that more fibronectin was adsorbed on hydrophilic NaHCO3-treated specimens. This result agrees with some previous researches, which showed increased protein adsorption on hydrophilic specimens [3537]. Protivínský et al. described continuously increasing fibronectin adsorption on highly hydrophilic surfaces treated by a high-temperature and high-concentration NaOH solution [35]. Milleret et al. found NaOH treated SLA Ti surfaces to partially heparinize whole human blood. Unstructured and discontinuous fibrinogen aggregates were observed on untreated group in their study, while a much denser mesh of fibrin fibers was recorded on NaOH treated group [15]. The initial binding of proteins relies on the physicochemical features of a surface, such as roughness, surface energy, and chemical composition [36, 38, 39]. The topographic features of the surfaces have particular consequences in terms of hydrophilicity. Before NaHCO3 treatment, microrough SLA Ti discs were hydrophobic. According to the Cassie-Baxter regime [3], the presence of air entrapment in the micropores on hydrophobic surfaces resists the contact of the solution which could have a negative effect of the surface contact area in the rough surfaces, inhibiting protein adsorption [39]. After NaHCO3 treatment, superhydrophilic SLA Ti surfaces were supposed to be filled with protein solution, which can increase the surface-protein contact area. Moreover, it is assumed by Rupp et al. that a higher surface free energy initiates the adsorption of proteins [11]. Supporting this assumption, studies have proved that SLA Ti specimens stored freshly in sodium chloride solution, as mentioned above, which exhibits a higher surface free energy, do significantly increase human plasma fibronectin adsorption [37]. Therefore, it is reasonable to consider that, after NaHCO3 treatment, higher surface free energy of SLA Ti surfaces also facilitated the adsorption of fibronectin. However, some previous studies showed that proteins tended to be adsorbed more extensively on hydrophobic surfaces [40, 41]. This disagreement between the protein adsorption results from different studies may be caused by the usage of a variety of proteins with different molecular properties and surfaces with different topographic features, while it still needs further research to investigate how protein types, surface roughness, and wettability affect protein adsorption.

The distribution feature of fibronectin on untreated and NaHCO3-treated surfaces was revealed with a significant difference in this study. The reasons behind this difference were also worth discussion. It is claimed that ionic strength of local environment takes active part in determining fibronectin’s molecular shape. That is to say, with increased ionic strength, fibronectin may display a more stretched distribution form [38]. In this study, the fibronectin spread to a more extended form on NaHCO3 discs, which were supposed to possess a higher ionic strength compared to untreated discs.

The adsorption of proteins on implant surfaces is essential because it can affect the early biological response of the surrounding microenvironment, which has an effect on the healing process as well as the final clinical outcomes of implants [42, 43]. Rivera-Chacon et al. proved this point by finding that increased cell attachment and proliferative capacity occurred on titanium surfaces with more fibronectin adsorption [44]. It was also evidenced that the alkali-treated implants on acid-etched surfaces are able to promote secondary stability in an earlier phases of implant site healing in dog experiments compared with the untreated implants [45]. Moreover, Held et al. recorded the results of alkali treated blasted and acid-etched implants in a series of clinical cases [46]. In their study, a number of blasted and acid-etched implants were placed in a group of patients with compromised bone density. Concluding from these experiments, the implants exhibited good stability quotient as well as vertical bone volume for at least 1 year after loading.

4.4. General Discussion on Modification of Ti Surface by Alkali Treatment

As NaHCO3 solution is weakly alkaline, Ti surfaces treated with NaHCO3 solution are expected to be able to generate similar effects to ones treated with NaOH solution. The results of hydrophilicity and physicochemical changes in this study were similar to those treated with NaOH solution [16]. However, some reports claimed that osteogenic differentiation of osteoprogenitor cells could be affected adversely by excessive alkalinization in the microenvironment of tissue-engineered constructs. Monfoulet et al. measured the range of usable pH values for alkalis with culture of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (hBMSC). They have observed that there was no cell proliferation at pH 8.85 and there were dead cells at pH 9.37. In contrast, cell proliferation was uninfluenced by alkaline that has a pH less than 8.27 [47]. Compared to 0.05 M NaOH (pH 12.7), 1 M NaHCO3 solution (pH 8.1) has a pH value closer to the one of human body fluid (pH 7.35–7.45). In addition, is one of the buffer components in blood and body fluid. NaHCO3 is considered to be more suitable for this application because of its relatively weak alkalinity and ease of preparation. Thus, the authors proposed an assumption that NaHCO3 solution may be a more optimized alternative to NaOH solution for the application of dental implants. To examine this hypothesis, future efforts are required.

Further researches should be proposed to firstly evaluate other characteristics of NaHCO3-treated SLA Ti surfaces, such as blood component adhesion, cell adhesion, osseointegrative potential, and influences on bone formation. Further, as stated above, differences in the biocompatibility of NaHCO3 and NaOH solution should be evaluated. Lastly, the authors believe it is also worth to examine that, apart from NaOH and NaHCO3 solution, whether other kinds of alkaline solution are suitable for being applied in similar Ti surface treatments.

5. Conclusions

This study describes and evaluates a novel, simple, and convenient method to enhance hydrophilicity of Ti surfaces with NaHCO3 solution. It was discovered that superhydrophilicity of SLA Ti surfaces can be obtained by reversible deprotonation and ion exchange processes. In addition, increased protein adsorption on NaHCO3-treated specimens was also observed and evaluated. In conclusion, this NaHCO3 treatment is a reliable method for enhancing the hydrophilicity and protein adsorption of SLA Ti surfaces. It was also proposed that due to the simplicity and biocompatibility of NaHCO3, NaHCO3 treatment might be considered as a clinically viable strategy to render superhydrophilicity to Ti specimens in the site of implantation without requirements for modifying manufacturing or storage methods of the implants. The influences on a Ti surface’s cell adhesion, cell proliferation, differentiation, and so forth after NaHCO3-treated will be addressed in our following studies. Moreover, the effects of NaHCO3 treatment on osseointegration should also be evaluated in future researches.

Conflict of Interests

The authors claim no conflict of interests.

Authors’ Contribution

Shengnan Jia and Yu Zhang contributed equally to this work.


This study was supported by a grant from the National Basic Research Program of China (973 Program, 2012CB933900). Titanium specimens were provided by Wego (Wego Jericom Biomaterials Co., Weihai, China). Technical assistance of engineer Mr. Jishu Yin (Wego Jericom Biomaterials Co., Weihai, China) is gratefully acknowledged.